Title
Unconstitutionality of Oil Deregulation Law
Law
Boc Memorandum
Decision Date
Dec 22, 1997
The Supreme Court's ruling on December 19, 1997, declared the Oil Deregulation Law (R.A. 8180) unconstitutional, reinstating previous tariff rates of 10% for crude oil and 20% for refined petroleum products, effective immediately.
A

Legal basis: oil deregulation nullity

  • The Memorandum treats Republic Act No. 8180 (the Act deregulating the downstream oil industry) as declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court.
  • The Memorandum states that the decision has the inevitable consequence of reviving the old law that Republic Act No. 8180 had repealed.
  • The Memorandum directs action consistent with the Supreme Court’s clear language regarding revival of repealed tariff regimes.
  • The Memorandum ties compliance to the Supreme Court ruling becoming final and executory on 19 December 1997.

Supreme Court finality date for compliance

  • The Memorandum fixes 19 December 1997 as the date when the declaration of nullity becomes final/executory.
  • The Memorandum orders that the relevant compliance actions be aligned with the period from April 16, 1996 (the deregulation effectivity reference) up to 19 December 1997.
  • The Memorandum requires implementation of the revived tariff rates effective 19 December 1997.

Immediate reporting obligation for BOC

  • The Memorandum directs submission of the list of oil shipments entered after the deregulation law took effect.
  • The mandated reporting period covers shipments entered after the Deregulation Act came into effect and specifically from April 16, 1996.
  • The reporting must cover entries up to 19 December 1997, when the nullity declaration becomes final/executory.
  • The reporting must include the amount of duties/taxes actually collected.

Duty/tax collections to be reported

  • The Memorandum requires reporting duties/taxes actually collected at 3% or 7%, as applicable “as the case may be.”
  • The Memorandum’s required reporting links the duty/tax rates collected to the entries covered within the April 16, 1996 to 19 December 1997 window.

Revival and imposition of old tariff rates

  • The Memorandum directs imposition of old rates resulting from the revival of the repealed tariff regime.
  • The revived tariff for crude oil is 10%.
  • The revived tariff for refined petroleum products is 20%.
  • The Memorandum orders these old rates to be effective 19 December 1997.
  • The Memorandum links the effective date of the old rates to the Supreme Court decision becoming final and executory on 19 December 1997.

Compliance instruction and enforcement posture

  • The Memorandum orders strict compliance with its numbered directives.
  • The compliance instructions are framed as directions to observe/comply.
  • The Memorandum issues a clear operational command to Customs to both report covered entries and apply the revived rates upon finality.

Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster, building context before diving into full texts. AI-powered analysis, always verify critical details.