Sindon vs. Alzate

A.M. No. RTJ-20-2576
Judge Alzate reprimanded for failing to recuse in wife’s notarial case; no liability for inaction or conspiracy. Atty. Querrer cleared.

Case Summary (A.M. No. RTJ-20-2576)

Factual Background

On September 6, 2017, counsel for Samson B. Sindon requested from the Office of the Clerk of Court a copy of the order that granted a notarial commission to Judge Alzate’s wife, Atty. Ma. Saniata Liwliwa Gonzales-Alzate. The request was received by Atty. Janice Siganay Querrer. Complainant alleged that the request was denied and the record suppressed, and further alleged a conspiracy between Judge Alzate and Atty. Querrer to grant an unwarranted benefit to Atty. Gonzales-Alzate. Respondents denied concealment and explained that Judge Alzate had instructed the clerk to inquire the purpose of the request and later directed that a copy be mailed; the record shows the order was mailed on September 11, 2017.

Procedural History

Samson B. Sindon filed the administrative complaint on October 12, 2017. Presiding Judge Raphiel F. Alzate and Atty. Janice Siganay Querrer filed separate Comments dated September 5, 2018. Atty. Gonzales-Alzate submitted an affidavit supporting respondents and alleging political motivation against her husband. On September 10, 2018, Sindon moved to withdraw the complaint. The Office of the Court Administrator prepared a Report and Recommendation which found that the clerk acted promptly but recommended that Judge Alzate be found guilty of violating Section 1, Rule 137 and be fined P11,000, and that the charges against Atty. Querrer be dismissed.

Parties' Contentions

Sindon alleged suppression of public records, failure to act promptly under RA 6713, conspiracy to give unwarranted benefit in violation of RA 3019, and that Judge Alzate failed to inhibit himself under Rule 137. Judge Alzate asserted that the request was dubious in form and purpose, that his wife complied with notarial requirements, and that there was no prohibition against granting a notarial commission to a spouse of an Executive Judge. Atty. Querrer related that she sought instructions from Judge Alzate and that the order was mailed two days after his direction. Atty. Gonzales-Alzate corroborated respondents and alleged the complaint was politically motivated.

OCA Findings and Recommendation

The OCA found that the letter-request was received September 6, 2017, and that the OCC mailed the requested order on September 11, 2017, within the fifteen-day period prescribed by Section 5(a), RA 6713. The OCA found no sufficient proof of conspiracy to give unwarranted benefit and noted that the clerk had no authority to grant or deny a notarial petition. The OCA concluded that Judge Alzate acted on his wife’s petition in violation of Section 1, Rule 137, and recommended redocketing as a regular administrative matter, fining Judge Alzate P11,000 with a stern warning, and dismissing charges against Atty. Querrer.

Issues Presented

The Court framed the issues as whether: one, Sindon’s motion to withdraw divested the Court of jurisdiction; two, respondents could be held administratively liable for inaction on the letter-request and for giving unwarranted benefit; and three, Judge Alzate was liable for hearing and granting his wife’s petition for notarial commission under Rule 137.

Jurisdiction Despite Withdrawal

The Court held that Sindon’s motion to withdraw did not deprive it of jurisdiction because administrative disciplinary proceedings serve to determine fitness to remain an officer of the court and thus concern public interest. The complainant is a witness rather than an indispensable party. The Court cited Ricafort v. Atty. Medina and Lim, Jr. v. Judge Magallanes to support that private desistance cannot frustrate the constitutional duty to supervise judiciary officials.

Promptness Under RA 6713

The Court agreed with the OCA that respondents acted promptly on the request. The OCC mailed the order within five days of receipt and therefore complied with Section 5(a), RA 6713, which requires a reply within fifteen working days that states the action taken on the request. The Court found no basis to hold Atty. Querrer or Judge Alzate liable for inaction on this ground.

Conspiracy and Unwarranted Benefit under RA 3019

The Court found no evidence of conspiracy or of giving an unwarranted benefit in violation of Section 3(e), RA 3019. The record indicated that the order granting the notarial commission had been prepared by a stenographer identified as “Maal,” and there was no proof that Atty. Querrer exerted influence or instructed action to secure a favorable result for Atty. Gonzales-Alzate. The mere performance by the clerk of administrative duties in receiving and transmitting documents did not establish collusion or corrupt practice.

Disqualification under Rule 137 and Judicial Conduct

The Court determined that Judge Alzate violated Section 1, Rule 137 by sitting on the petition of his wife for a notarial commission. The Court observed that to “sit” in a case extends to acts of a judicial nature including issuing orders and resolving motions. The Court relied on Mayor Sales v. Judge Calvan and related precedents to conclude that the prohibition applies to summary and non-adversarial proceedings that require the judge to exercise discretion. The Court noted that Section 4, Rule III of the 2004 Rules on Notarial Practice required the Executive Judge to conduct a summary hearing to determine sufficiency and compliance, which placed the judge in a position requiring impartial adjudication. The Court also invoked Section 5, Canon III of the New Code of Judicial Conduct which mandates disqualification where a judge’s impartiality may reasonably be questioned.

Comparative Authorities and Prior Decisions

The Court cited Villaluz v. Judge Mijares and De la Cruz v. Judge Bersamira to illustrate that non-adversarial nature does not excuse the duty to recuse where familial ties create an appearance of bias. The Court emphasized that judges must not only be impartial but must also appear to be impartial, and that waiver of procedural safeguards or special favor to relatives undermines public confidence.

Disposition and Penalty

The Court found Judge Raphiel F. Alzate guilty of violating Section 1, Rule 137 and imposed a reprimand with warning that a repetition would be dealt with more severely. The Court declined to adop

...continue reading

Philippine legal research, made clearer
AI-generated research aids. Verify with Full Text.