Sindon vs. Alzate

A.M. No. RTJ-20-2576
Judge Alzate reprimanded for failing to recuse in wife’s notarial case; no liability for inaction or conspiracy. Atty. Querrer cleared.

Case Digest (A.M. No. RTJ-20-2576)

Facts:

Samson B. Sindon v. Presiding Judge Raphiel F. Alzate, Regional Trial Court, Branch 1, Bangued, Abra, A.M. No. RTJ-20-2576 (formerly OCA IPI No. 18-4864-RTJ), January 29, 2020, First Division, Lazaro-Javier, J., writing for the Court.

Complainant Samson Sindon filed an administrative complaint dated October 12, 2017 against respondent Presiding Judge Raphiel Alzate (RTC, Branch 1, Bangued, Abra) and Atty. Janice Siganay Querrer, Clerk of Court of the same branch, alleging violations of Section 3(e) of R.A. No. 3019, Section 5 of R.A. No. 6713, and Section 1 of Rule 137 of the Rules of Court. Sindon alleged that on September 6, 2017 his counsel, Atty. Jean Phebie De Mesa of the Reynaldo Cortes Law Office, requested from the Office of the Clerk of Court (OCC) a copy of the order granting a notarial commission to Judge Alzate’s wife, Atty. Ma. Saniata Liwliwa Gonzales-Alzate, but that Atty. Querrer denied the request and the record was allegedly suppressed.

Sindon further charged that Judge Alzate and Atty. Querrer conspired to give unwarranted benefit to Atty. Gonzales-Alzate (a violation of R.A. No. 3019, Sec. 3(e)): the complaint alleged that Atty. Querrer prepared the order granting the notarial commission and handed it to Judge Alzate for approval, and that both failed to act promptly on the letter-request (an alleged breach of R.A. No. 6713, Sec. 5(a)). Sindon also alleged that Judge Alzate should have recused under Rule 137, Sec. 1 for acting on a matter involving his wife.

Respondent Judge Alzate, in his Comment (dated September 5, 2018), denied wrongdoing, questioned the authenticity and purpose of the letter-request, and said the petition for notarial commission was granted only after his wife complied with requirements; he maintained nothing in the notarial rules prohibited grant to a spouse of an executive judge. Clerk Atty. Querrer likewise explained she informed Judge Alzate about the request, asked for its purpose, and followed his instruction — she later mailed a copy of the order on September 11, 2017.

Atty. Gonzales-Alzate submitted an affidavit corroborating respondents and accusing Mayor Jendricks Luna of instigating Sindon to file the complaint. On September 10, 2018 Sindon moved to withdraw the complaint, claiming he was coaxed into signing it and that no one properly explained the allegations.

The Office of the Court Administrator (OCA) investigated and, in its Report and Recommendation, found that the OCC received the request on September 6, 2017 and mailed the order on September 11, 2017 — within the fifteen (15) working days required by R.A. No. 6713, Sec. 5(a) — and therefore respondents’ alleged inaction and suppression were unproven. The OCA also found no evidence of conspiracy; the order of June 30, 2017 granting the notarial commission was prepared by a stenographer and the clerk lacked authority to grant or deny the petition. However, the OCA concluded Judge Alzate violated Section 1, Rule 137 by acting on his wife’s petition and recommended the complaint be redocketed as a regular administrative matter, that Judge Alzate be found guilty of violating Rule 137 a...(Pro-only)

Issues:

  • Does Sindon’s motion to withdraw the complaint deprive the Court of jurisdiction to proceed with the administrative case?
  • Can Judge Alzate and Atty. Querrer be held administratively liable for purported inaction on Sindon’s letter-request or for conspiring to give unwarranted benefit to a third party?
  • Did Judge Alzate violate Section 1, Rule 137 of the Rules of Court by hearing and granting his wife...(Pro-only)

Ruling:

  • (Pro-only)

Ratio:

  • (Pro-only)

Doctrine:

  • (Pro-only)

Philippine legal research, made clearer
AI-generated research aids. Verify with Full Text.