Case Summary (A.M. No. MTJ-22-007)
Factual Background
Complainants alleged that during the preliminary conference in Civil Case No. M-MNL-18-08450-SC, an unlawful detainer action before Branch 26 of the MeTC, Judge Lorredo made remarks that prejudged the merits, displayed obvious bias and partiality against them, and injected his religious beliefs and impressions about homosexuality into the proceedings. They averred that his conduct included homophobic innuendo and irrelevant religious commentary that affected the course of the preliminary conference.
Procedural History in the Underlying Civil Case
Complainants moved for voluntary inhibition of Judge Lorredo for bias and partiality, but the motion was denied. Judge Lorredo thereafter issued a decision in the ejectment case adverse to complainants, a decision which complainants duly appealed. Parallel to the appeal, they filed the instant administrative complaint alleging violations of specified provisions of the New Code of Judicial Conduct.
Respondent's Explanation
In his Comment, Judge Lorredo denied prejudging the case and contended that he used Biblical passages only to guide parties toward settlement. He stated that one of the complainants had identified the other as homosexual and asserted that his warnings about divine punishment were intended as moral admonition. He further claimed that he had "settled 101 cases using the Bible" and justified his remarks as grounded on complainants’ own admissions about their lack of ownership and the law on ejectment.
Judicial Integrity Board Recommendation
The Judicial Integrity Board (JIB) reviewed the records and recommended re-docketing the matter as a regular administrative case. The JIB found that Judge Lorredo declared at the preliminary conference that complainants were not owners and must vacate, thereby virtually prejudging the case. The JIB also faulted him for using the Bible in his judicial conduct and for making irrelevant remarks about homosexuality, concluding these acts constituted grave misconduct. It recommended a fine of P40,000.00 and further admonitions.
Issue Before the Court
The sole issue posed to the Supreme Court was whether Judge Lorredo should be held administratively liable for his conduct at the preliminary conference and related acts, and, if so, what penalty should be imposed.
Prior Administrative Record
The Court took into account that this was not Judge Lorredo’s first administrative proceeding. In Magno v. Lorredo the Court previously found him guilty of conduct unbecoming for insulting and offensive remarks in a different preliminary conference, and imposed a fine of P5,000.00 with warning. That prior sanction informed the Court’s assessment of recidivism and appropriate discipline in the present case.
Findings of Impropriety and Violations of Canons
The Court agreed with the JIB that Judge Lorredo’s conduct during the preliminary conference and his subsequent pleadings violated provisions of the New Code of Judicial Conduct, specifically Sections 1 and 6 of Canon 4 (Propriety), Sections 1, 2 and 3 of Canon 5 (Equality), and Sections 1 and 2 of Canon 2 (Integrity). The Court found that his use of religious admonition, homophobic language, and apparent linking of complainants’ sexual orientation to divine punishment were improper, irrelevant to the ejectment proceedings, and impaired both the dignity of the office and the appearance of impartiality.
Work-Related Sexual Harassment Finding
The Court further held that Judge Lorredo’s derogatory and degrading remarks about complainants’ sexual orientation amounted to work-related sexual harassment under CSC Resolution No. 01-0940. It identified Section 3(a)(3), Rule III and Section 53(B)(3), Rule X as those classifying such derogatory innuendoes as a less grave offense punishable by fine or suspension.
Assessment of Actual Bias and Disqualification Elements
The Court examined whether the conduct amounted to actual partiality or disqualification under the standards articulated in Cabanero v. Canon and related authorities. It reiterated that disqualification requires clear and convincing evidence of personal interest, extrajudicial bias, or an opinion on the merits based on sources other than the record. The Court found insufficient extrinsic evidence of such personal interest or extrajudicial bias here. Some of the judge’s comments were based, as he maintained, on complainants’ own admissions of nonownership, and opinions formed in the course of proceedings do not, standing alone, establish disqualification.
Characterization of Offenses and Rationale for Penalty
While affirming that Judge Lorredo committed multiple violations of the New Code and the CSC rules, the Court declined to elevate those violations to the level of gross misconduct. The Court explained that gross misconduct requires elements such as fraud, corruption, bad faith, or deliberate intent to cause an injustice, which were not established. Accordingly, the Court classified the infractions as: simple misconduct for the overbearing demeanor and undue pressure to settle; conduct unbecoming of a judge for the offensive and untoward language; and a less grave sexual harassment offense under CSC Resolution No. 01-0940 for derogatory remarks about sexual orientation.
Penalties Imposed
Applying the penalties under Rule 140 of the Rules of Court, as amended, and the disciplin
...continue reading
Case Syllabus (A.M. No. MTJ-22-007)
Parties and Procedural Posture
- Marcelino Espejon and Erickson Cabonita filed a verified Complaint dated January 7, 2019 against Hon. Jorge Emmanuel M. Lorredo for prejudging, bias and partiality.
- The administrative complaint arose from the conduct of the preliminary conference in Civil Case No. M-MNL-18-08450-SC, an unlawful detainer action adjudicated by Judge Lorredo.
- Judge Lorredo denied the complainants' Motion for Voluntary Inhibition and subsequently rendered a decision adverse to complainants which they timely appealed.
- The Judicial Integrity Board (JIB) investigated and transmitted a Report and Recommendation finding violations and proposing administrative sanctions.
Key Factual Allegations
- Complainants alleged that Judge Lorredo made statements during the preliminary conference that prejudged the ejectment case and revealed bias against complainants' sexual orientation.
- The transcript of stenographic notes showed Judge Lorredo repeatedly asked about complainants' relationship and repeatedly invoked religious language and Biblical passages.
- Judge Lorredo linked complainants' alleged sexual orientation to divine punishment and to the propriety of ejectment in the subject case.
- The TSN reflected the judge's repeated exhortations citing Thou shall not steal and other scriptural passages to urge complainants to vacate the property.
- Judge Lorredo candidly admitted in his Comment that he had "settled 101 cases using the Bible" and defended his remarks as efforts to guide parties toward settlement.
Respondent's Position
- Judge Lorredo denied prejudging the case and maintained that his remarks were intended to warn complainants about God's punishment and to encourage settlement.
- Judge Lorredo asserted that the TSN would show one complainant referred to the other as homosexual and that complainants admitted tolerance by the landlord, which informed his ejectment-related observations.
- Judge Lorredo argued that his statements were rooted in applicable ejectment principles and in his perceived duty to exhort parties toward amicable settlement.
Judicial Integrity Board Recommendation
- The JIB found that Judge Lorredo effectively prejudged the merits by declaring that complainants were not owners and must vacate during a preliminary conference devoted to settlement.
- The JIB concluded that Judge Lorredo used the Bible in a manner incompatible with insulating judicial decision-making from personal religious beliefs.
- The JIB characterized the acts as grave misconduct for flagrant disregard of Canon 3 of the New Code of Judicial Conduct and recommended re-docketing as a regular administrative matter and a fine of P40,000 with a stern warning and remedial advice.
Issue
- The sole issue before the Court was whether Judge Lorredo should be held administratively liable for his conduct during the preliminary conference and related misconduct.
Court's Findings
- The Court ado