Espejon vs. Lorredo

A.M. No. MTJ-22-007
Judge Lorredo's biased remarks, prejudgment, and inappropriate use of religious references during a case hearing violated judicial conduct, leading to fines and suspension.

Case Digest (A.M. No. MTJ-22-007)

Facts:

Marcelino Espejon and Erickson Cabonita v. Hon. Jorge Emmanuel M. Lorredo, A.M. No. MTJ-22-007 (Formerly OCA IPI No. 19-3026-MTJ), March 09, 2022, Supreme Court First Division, Caguioa, J., writing for the Court.

Complainants filed a verified administrative complaint on January 7, 2019 against Judge Jorge Emmanuel M. Lorredo, Presiding Judge of Branch 26, Metropolitan Trial Court (MeTC), Manila, alleging that during the preliminary conference in Civil Case No. M‑MNL‑18‑08450‑SC (an unlawful detainer case filed by Myrna Alcantara et al.) the judge prejudged the merits, manifested bias and partiality, and introduced irrelevant religious and homophobic remarks into the proceedings. Complainants moved for Judge Lorredo’s voluntary inhibition, which the judge denied; he later issued a decision in the ejectment case unfavorable to complainants, who appealed the decision while also pursuing the administrative complaint.

Judge Lorredo denied prejudgment and bias, explaining in his Comment that his remarks were intended to admonish litigants using Biblical teachings—he stated he had “settled 101 cases using the Bible”—and that his observations were grounded on complainants’ own admissions about their non‑ownership of the property and applicable legal principles on tolerance and ejectment. The Judicial Integrity Board (JIB) reviewed the matter, concluded the judge had effectively prejudged the case, improperly injected his religious beliefs, and made homophobic remarks irrelevant to the controversy, and recommended re‑docketing the complaint as an administrative matter and finding him guilty of grave misconduct with a P40,000 fine.

The Court noted Judge Lorredo’s prior administrative sanction in Magno v. Lorredo, where he was found guilty of conduct unbecoming a judge and fined P5,000 for insulting statements during a preliminary conference. The JIB’s recommendation, Judge Lorredo’s Comment, the transcript excerpts of the preliminary conference, the JIB Rep...(Pro-only)

Issues:

  • Whether Judge Lorredo should be held administratively liable for his conduct during the preliminary conference in Civil Case No. M‑MNL‑18‑08450‑SC (i.e., prejudging, manifesting bias, injecting religious views and homophobic slurs, and committing work‑related sexual harassment), and if so, what sanc...(Pro-only)

Ruling:

  • (Pro-only)

Ratio:

  • (Pro-only)

Doctrine:

  • (Pro-only)

Philippine legal research, made clearer
AI-generated research aids. Verify with Full Text.