Case Summary (G.R. No. 206484)
Allegations Against the Respondent
Judge Pajunar faced a series of allegations in the administrative complaint filed by Mayor Ausejo. The charges included unauthorized absences from his judicial duties, ignorance of the law, and exhibiting partiality and unfairness in his role as a municipal judge. These serious allegations prompted an investigation into the conduct of the respondent, necessitating a fair hearing to assess the validity of the claims.
Jurisdiction and Initial Proceedings
The administrative complaint was initially referred to the Executive Judge of Dumaguete City, Macario P. Santos, as the jurisdiction over such matters rested with the Department of Justice at that time. The respondent offered an answer contesting the allegations against him, asserting their lack of truthfulness. Following this, a hearing was scheduled, during which the complainant's witness provided testimony.
Manifestation to Dismiss the Case
During the course of the hearings, the complainant's counsel expressed concerns regarding the reliability of the testimonies from the witnesses. Notably, he identified inconsistencies in their statements and concluded that continuing the investigation would likely fail to sustain the charges against Judge Pajunar. Therefore, he respectfully requested that the administrative case be dismissed and the investigation concluded, indicating a significant shift in the complainant's position.
Hearing Outcomes and Recommendations
Following the complainant’s counsel’s manifestation, Judge Macario P. Santos recommended the dismissal of the case. The recommendation arose from the acknowledgment that the evidence presented was insufficient to substantiate the allegations against Judge Pajunar. The recommendation emphasized that the legal standards for such complaints had not been met, paving the way for resolution.
Final Resolution
Ultimately, the matter was refer
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 206484)
Background of the Case
- The case involves an administrative complaint lodged by Alfonso S. Ausejo, who was the Mayor of Bacong, Negros Oriental, against Municipal Judge Gaudencio P. Pajunar.
- The complainant accused Judge Pajunar of several infractions, including absences without permission, ignorance of the law, and demonstrating partiality and unfairness in his judicial duties.
- The jurisdiction over the matter was initially vested in the Department of Justice, which referred the case to Executive Judge Macario P. Santos of Dumaguete City for investigation.
Proceedings and Testimonies
- Judge Pajunar responded to the accusations, claiming that the charges were unfounded and sought for absolution.
- A hearing was conducted; however, it was noted that only one witness testified at the initial session.
- During a subsequent session, the counsel for the complainant expressed concerns regarding the credibility of the witnesses