Case Digest (G.R. No. 162368)
Facts:
On February 29, 1996, Taiwan Kolin Corporation, Ltd. filed Trademark Application No. 4-1996-106310 for the mark KOLIN, later revived and limited to Class 9 goods including television sets and DVD players; Kolin Electronics Co., Inc. opposed, citing its prior registration of KOLIN for power-supply and audio accessories. The Bureau of Legal Affairs, IPO denied Taiwan Kolin's application; the IPO Director General reversed and granted the application limited to television and DVD player; the Court of Appeals reversed the Director General and reinstated the BLA-IPO decision, prompting this Rule 45 petition.Issues:
- Is Taiwan Kolin entitled to registration of the mark KOLIN for television sets and DVD players?
- Are the goods covered by Taiwan Kolin and Kolin Electronics sufficiently related to render registration likely to cause confusion?
Ruling:
The petition was granted. The Court reversed and set aside the Court of Appeals Decision and Resolution, an Case Digest (G.R. No. 162368)
Facts:
- Parties and filings
- Taiwan Kolin Corporation, Ltd. filed Trademark Application No. 4-1996-106310 on February 29, 1996 for the mark KOLIN covering a combination of goods including colored televisions, refrigerators, air conditioners, electric fans and water dispensers under Classes 9, 11, and 21 of the Nice Classification (NCL).
- The application was considered abandoned for failure to respond to IPO Paper No. 5 requiring election of one class, but was revived through Application Serial No. 4-2002-011002 filed December 27, 2002 with an election of Class 9 covering television sets, cassette recorders, VCDs, amplifiers, camcorders and other audio/video electronic equipment, flat iron, vacuum cleaners, cordless handsets, videophones, facsimile machines, teleprinters, cellular phones and automatic goods vending machines; the application was published.
- Opposition and prior disputes between the parties
- On July 13, 2006 Kolin Electronics Co., Inc. opposed the revived application in Inter Partes Case No. 14-2006-00096, alleging identity or confusing similarity with its registered mark KOLIN dated November 23, 2003 covering automatic voltage regulator, converter, recharger, stereo booster, AC-DC regulated power supply, step-down transformer, and PA amplified AC-DC under Class 9.
- The parties had previously litigated Inter Partes Case No. 14-1998-00050 before the IPO where Taiwan Kolin claimed priority based on a Taipei registration dated December 1, 1988; the BLA-IPO declined to accord priority absent evidence of use in the Philippines, the IPO Director General affirmed, and the Court of Appeals affirmed on July 31, 2006, allowing Kolin Electronics to register its mark.
- Proceedings at the Intellectual Property Office
- By Decision dated August 16, 2007, the Bureau of Legal Affairs of the IPO (BLA-IPO) sustained the opposition and rejected Application No. 4-1996-106310 under Section 123(d) of the Intellectual Property Code (IP Code) on the ground that the mark was identical with a registered mark of a different proprietor for the same or closely-related goods; the BLA-IPO also relied on alleged proof of actual confusion in consumer e-mails.
- Taiwan Kolin moved for reconsideration which the BLA-IPO denied on January 26, 2009; Taiwan Kolin appealed to the IPO Director General.
- IPO Director General decision and subsequent appeals
- On November 23, 2011 the IPO Director General reversed the BLA-IPO and granted the appeal, giving due course to Application No. 4-1996-106310 subject to a use limitation to televisions and DVD players, reasoning that product classification alone cannot be decisive and that emphasis must be on the similarity of products rather than arbitrary classification.
- Kolin Electronics appea...(Subscriber-Only)
Issues:
- Primary issues presented
- Whether Taiwan Kolin is entitled to register the mark KOLIN for television sets and DVD players despite Kolin Electronics' prior registration of KOLIN for goods under Class 9.
- Whether the goods covered by Taiwan Kolin's application (televisions and DVD players) are the same as or closely related to the goods covered by Kolin Electronics' registration such that registration should be refused under Section 123(d)...(Subscriber-Only)
Ruling:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Ratio:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Doctrine:
- (Subscriber-Only)