Case Digest (A.M. No. MTJ-91-595)
Facts:
- Priscilla Imbing filed a complaint against Judge Benjamin C. Tiongson.
- The complaint originated from a letter dated July 25, 1991, sent to former President Corazon C. Aquino and later forwarded to the Office of the Court Administrator.
- Imbing accused Tiongson of abandoning and failing to support their two children.
- The couple married on November 1, 1981, according to Subanen tribal customs, officiated by tribal head Lantay Imbing.
- They had two children: Anna Freya (born September 19, 1982) and Benjamin Jr. (born December 6, 1983).
- Tiongson abandoned Imbing and their children after being assigned to Manila, leaving them without financial support.
- Imbing sought a monthly deduction of P5,000 from Tiongson's salary and a third of his retirement benefits for their children's education.
- Tiongson denied the marriage and paternity of Benjamin Jr., claiming Imbing was already married to another man at the time of their alleged marriage.
- He acknowledged paternity of Anna Freya but claimed to have sent P1,000 monthly for her support.
- Despite Imbing withdrawing her complaint, the Supreme Court continued its investigation due to public interest in judicial conduct.
- The investigation confirmed Tiongson fathered a child with Imbing while knowing of her existing marriage, raising concerns about his moral integrity.
- The Executive Judge recommended Tiongson's dismissal for gross immorality, leading to the Supreme Court's final decision.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court found Judge Benjamin C. Tiongson guilty of gross immorality and dismissed him from service, forfeiting his retirement benefits and disqualifying him from reemployment in government service.
- The Court ruled that Imbing's withdrawal of the comp...(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The Supreme Court emphasized that judges must uphold the highest standards of morality in both their professional and personal lives.
- Tiongson's actions, specifically fathering a child with Imbing while awa...continue reading
Case Digest (A.M. No. MTJ-91-595)
Facts:
The case involves Priscilla Imbing as the complainant and Judge Benjamin C. Tiongson as the respondent. The events leading to the case began with a letter dated July 25, 1991, addressed to former President Corazon C. Aquino, which was subsequently endorsed to the Office of the Court Administrator on September 6, 1991. In this letter, Judge Tiongson was accused of abandoning and failing to support his two children with Imbing. The couple had married on November 1, 1981, in accordance with the customs of the Subanen tribe, officiated by tribal head Lantay Imbing. They lived together in Pagadian City and had two children: Anna Freya, born on September 19, 1982, and Benjamin Jr., born on December 6, 1983. However, after Tiongson was assigned to Manila, he abandoned Imbing and their children for another woman, leading Imbing to return to Zamboanga del Sur without financial support. Imbing sought a monthly deduction of P5,000 from Tiongson's salary and a third of his retirement benefits for their children's education.
In response, Tiongson denied the marriage and paternity of Benjamin Jr., claiming that Imbing was already married to another man at the time of their alleged marriage. He acknowledged paternity of Anna Freya but argued that he had been sending P1,000 monthly for her support. Desp...