Title
Prohibiting Fee Requirement in QC Public Schools
Law
Quezon City Ordinance No. Sp-2294, S-2014
Decision Date
Jul 9, 2014
Quezon City prohibits public school authorities and Parent-Teacher Association members from requiring any fees or voluntary contributions as a condition for student enrollment or graduation, ensuring access to free education for all families.

Law Summary

Problem Addressed by the Ordinance

  • Despite constitutional guarantees, some public school authorities and PTA members require fees or contributions as a condition for student enrollment or graduation.
  • This practice causes hesitation among poor families to send their children to school due to potential financial burdens.

Existing DepEd Policies on Collections

  • Department of Education (DepEd) allows certain voluntary contributions such as Boy/Girl Scouts membership, Anti-TB Fund Drive, PTA, School Publication, and Student Organizations memberships.
  • Collections must be voluntary and cannot be a prerequisite for admission or graduation.
  • DepEd Orders No. 19, S-2008, No. 40, S-2008 and No. 40, S-2009 implement a "No Collection Policy" in all public elementary and secondary schools.

Issue of Non-Compliance and Recurrent Violations

  • Despite DepEd Orders, some school authorities and PTA officers continue to enforce mandatory contributions.
  • This creates perception that public education favors middle-class and affluent families.
  • Numerous complaints have been filed with barangay governments and concerned offices.

Responsibility of School Authorities and PTA

  • School authorities, as DepEd subordinates, are required to comply with the "No Collection Policy."
  • PTA organizations must adhere to all existing and future DepEd policies including the "No Collection Policy" as mandated by DepEd Order No. 54, S-2009.

Impact of Illegal Collection Practices

  • Unlawful collections contribute to increased out-of-school youth and street children, adversely affecting public order and safety.
  • These practices hinder accessibility to education for economically disadvantaged students.

Legal Authority and Enactment of Ordinance

  • Pursuant to Section 458 (a)(1)(v) of the Local Government Code of 1991, the Quezon City Council may enact ordinances to prevent fraudulent monetary practices.
  • The ordinance aims to eliminate fees or contributions as a mandatory condition for enrollment or graduation in public schools.

Prohibitions Imposed by the Ordinance

  • School authorities and PTA officers/members are prohibited from requiring any fee or voluntary contribution as a condition precedent for student enrollment or graduation.

Definitions

  • "School Authorities": School head, principal, teachers, non-teaching personnel, and other school-connected staff.
  • "Parent-Teacher Association (PTA)": School organizations of parents and teachers, whether SEC registered or recognized by the school.
  • "PTA Members": Parents and teachers who are members of the PTA with children enrolled in the school.
  • "Authorized/Voluntary Contribution": Voluntary contributions allowed by DepEd.

Transparency and Posting Requirements

  • School Head, Principal, and PTA President must conspicuously post school fees and authorized voluntary contributions on a bulletin board within school premises.
  • A bold notification must indicate that such fees and contributions are voluntary.

Monitoring and Enforcement

  • The City Schools Superintendent of Quezon City shall oversee compliance with the ordinance in all public elementary and high schools.

Penalties for Violations

  • Violation of the prohibition on mandatory fees and contributions shall be penalized by a fine of Five Thousand Pesos (P5,000.00) or imprisonment for one year, or both.
  • Violation of posting requirements incurs a fine of One Thousand Pesos (P1,000.00) each for the School Head, Principal, and PTA President.
  • Penalties are imposed without prejudice to administrative cases.

Severability Clause

  • If any provision is declared invalid or unconstitutional, other sections shall remain effective.

Repealing Clause

  • Existing inconsistent ordinances, resolutions, executive orders, and administrative issuances are repealed or modified accordingly.

Effectivity

  • The ordinance takes effect fifteen (15) days after publication in a newspaper of general circulation.

Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster—building context before diving into full texts.