Title
Negotiable Instruments Law of the Philippines
Law
Act No. 2031
Decision Date
Feb 3, 1911
This Philippine Jurisprudence case explores the requirements, provisions, and liabilities related to negotiable instruments, including the form, interpretation, and negotiation, indorsement and rights and liabilities of parties, presentment for payment, notice of dishonor, and discharge of negotiable instruments.

Law Summary

Certain Sum Defined

  • The payable sum is certain even if it includes interest, installments, exchange rate variation, collection costs, or attorney fees upon default.

Unconditional Promise or Order

  • An order or promise to pay is unconditional despite references to specific funds or transactional statements.
  • A promise to pay only from a specific fund is conditional and not unconditional.

Determinable Future Time

  • Defined as payment at a fixed period after date or sight, on or before a fixed or determinable date, or after a specified event that is certain to occur.
  • Payment upon an uncertain contingency is not negotiable.

Additional Provisions and Negotiability

  • Additional acts beyond payment of money void negotiability.
  • Provisions authorizing sale of collateral, confession of judgment, waiver of protections, or options other than money payment do not affect negotiability.
  • Illegal provisions remain invalid.

Instrument Validity Despite Omissions

  • Valid even if undated, lacks specified value, place of issue or payment, bears a seal, or specifies a particular kind of money.
  • Does not repeal laws requiring statement of consideration.

Payable on Demand Instruments

  • Payable on demand if expressed as such or no time is stated.
  • An instrument issued or endorsed overdue is payable on demand by the party making, accepting, or endorsing it.

Payable to Order

  • Payable to order when drawn to the order of a specified person or to him or his order.
  • Payee must be reasonably identified.
  • Payee can be the maker, drawer, drawee, one or multiple payees, or holders of an office.

Payable to Bearer

  • Payable to bearer if so expressed, payable to a named person or bearer, fictitious payee known to maker, non-personal payee name, or last blank endorsement.

Use of Terms and Dates

  • Instrument terms need not follow the Act’s language but must clearly show intention to comply.
  • Dates on instrument are prima facie evidence of the true date.
  • Antedating or postdating does not invalidate unless for illegal purposes.
  • Date may be inserted if missing; wrong date does not avoid the instrument for holders in due course.

Handling of Blanks

  • Possessor may fill blanks with prima facie authority.
  • Completed instruments valid against subsequent holders in due course even if filled incorrectly but within reason and authority.
  • Unauthorized completion of undelivered blanks invalid against prior parties.

Delivery and Contract Completion

  • Delivery is essential to effect the contract.
  • Delivery must be by or authorized by the party making, drawing, accepting, or endorsing until reaching holder in due course.
  • Delivery presumed valid if instrument held by holder in due course or former signatory.

Interpretation of Ambiguous Instruments

  • Discrepancies between words and figures favor words unless ambiguous.
  • Interest runs from date of instrument or issue if undated.
  • Written provisions prevail over printed ones.
  • Ambiguity as to instrument type may be treated as bill or note.
  • Unclear signer capacity deemed indorser.
  • Multiple signers on "I promise to pay" notes are jointly and severally liable.

Signatures and Capacity

  • No liability without signature except as provided.
  • Trade or assumed names bind as real names.
  • Agents may sign with authority, established like other agency.
  • Signing in representative capacity discloses when liability is to principal only.
  • Signatures by procuration indicate limited authority.
  • Indorsement by infants or corporations transfers property without binding liability.
  • Forged signatures are void unless forgery is estopped.

Consideration Presumptions and Definitions

  • Instruments presumed issued for value; signatories presumed parties for value.
  • Value includes any consideration supporting a simple contract, including antecedent debts.
  • Holder for value includes those giving value at any time, including holders with liens.
  • Absence or failure of consideration is a defense except against holders in due course.
  • Accommodation parties sign without value to lend name, still liable to holders for value.

Negotiation of Instruments

  • Negotiation is transfer making transferee the holder.
  • Bearer instruments negotiated by delivery; order instruments by endorsement plus delivery.
  • Endorsements must be on the instrument or attached paper and cover entire instrument.
  • Endorsements can be special (naming indorsee), blank (payable to bearer), restrictive, qualified, or conditional.
  • Restrictive endorsements limit negotiation and vest title in trust or agency.
  • Qualified endorsements limit indorser liability (e.g., "without recourse").
  • Conditional endorsements do not affect the payer's duty to pay.
  • Special indorsements to two or more payees require all signatures unless authorized.
  • Misdescribed or misspelled payee names may be endorsed as described with optional correct signature.
  • Endorsement presumed timely and at place of instrument date.
  • Negotiable character continues until restrictive endorsement or discharge.
  • Holder may strike out unnecessary endorsements.
  • Transfer without endorsement vests title but requires endorsement to qualify as holder in due course.
  • Prior parties may reissue and negotiate back subject to prior personal liability.

Rights of Holders

  • Holder may sue in own name; payment to holder discharges instrument.
  • Holder in due course requirements: Complete and regular on face, obtained before due date without notice of dishonor, in good faith and for value, without notice of title defects.
  • Not holder in due course if instrument payable on demand negotiated unreasonably late.
  • Notice of defects before full payment limits holder in due course rights to amount paid.
  • Defective title includes fraud, duress, illegality.
  • Holder in due course free from prior defects and may sue all liable parties.
  • Other holders subject to all original defenses; those deriving from holder in due course enjoy same rights if not parties to fraud.
  • Burden on holder to prove holder in due course if title defective.

Liability of Parties

  • Maker promises to pay instrument according to tenor, admitting payee existence and capacity.
  • Drawer admits payee existence and capacity, guarantees payment upon presentment and payment if dishonored unless liability limited.
  • Acceptor engages to pay according to acceptance, admitting drawer's signature genuineness and payee's capacity.
  • Signers not designated as maker, drawer, or acceptor are indorsers unless otherwise specified.
  • Irregular indorsers liable according to payee's role and circumstances.
  • Negotiation warranties include genuineness, title, capacity of prior parties, and knowledge of defects.
  • General indorsers warrant validity and subsistence at indorsement and agree to pay if dishonored.
  • Indorsement liability follows the order of indorsements; joint indorsers are jointly and severally liable.
  • Agents negotiating without indorsement liable unless disclosing principal.

Presentment for Payment

  • Presentment not necessary to charge maker or acceptor but necessary to charge drawer and indorsers except as excused.
  • Non-demand instruments must be presented on due date; demand instruments must be presented within reasonable time.
  • Presentment must be made by holder or authorized person, at reasonable hour, proper place, to person primarily liable.
  • Place of presentment follows instrument's specified place or usual business/residence.
  • Instrument must be exhibited on presentment and delivered up upon payment.
  • Presentment at bank during banking hours is required.
  • Presentment to personal representative if liable party dead.
  • Presentment to any partner suffices for partner liability even after dissolution; multiple non-partner debtors must all be presented.
  • Presentment not required where drawer or indorser has no right to expect payment.
  • Delay excused when beyond holder's control.
  • Presentment dispensed with where reasonably impractical, drawee is fictitious, or waived.
  • Dishonor by nonpayment occurs if payment refused after presentment or presentment excused and unpaid when overdue.
  • Immediate recourse accrues to parties secondarily liable upon dishonor.
  • Maturity computed excluding start day, including payment day; holidays postpone payment.
  • Payment in due course means payment at or after maturity to holder in good faith without defect notice.

Notice of Dishonor

  • Notice required to drawer and each indorser or they are discharged except as otherwise provided.
  • Notice may be given by holder or any party liable who may seek reimbursement.
  • Notice by agent valid.
  • Notice benefits subsequent holders and parties with recourse.
  • Notice must be given within prescribed times either in same or different places.
  • Notice may be given personally or by mail; proper address rules apply.
  • Notice may be waived expressly or impliedly.
  • Protest not required except for foreign bills; waiver of protest also waives presentment and notice of dishonor.
  • Delay excused when beyond holder control.

Discharge of Instruments

  • Discharged by due payment, cancellation, acts discharging simple contracts, or principal debtor becoming holder after maturity.
  • Secondary parties discharged by discharge of instrument, cancellation of signature, discharge of prior party, tender of payment, release of principal debtor unless reserved, or agreement extending time unless consented.
  • Secondary party paying instrument retains rights against prior parties.
  • Holder may renounce rights expressly; unconditional renunciation discharges instrument but not rights of holder in due course without notice.
  • Unintentional cancellations ineffective; burden of proof on party alleging unintentional cancellation.
  • Material alteration voids instrument except against consenting parties and does not affect holder in due course.
  • Material alterations include changes to date, sum, time or place, parties, currency, or adding place of payment.

Bill of Exchange and Acceptance

  • Bill of exchange: unconditional order in writing, signed, payable on demand or future time to order or bearer.
  • Bill does no
...continue reading

Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster—building context before diving into full texts.