Title
BIR Reg. on Deductibility of Bad Debts
Law
Bir Revenue Regulations No. 5-99
Decision Date
Mar 10, 1999
BIR Revenue Regulations No. 5-99 establishes the criteria for deducting bad debts from gross income, requiring taxpayers to demonstrate that debts are worthless and uncollectible, while outlining specific conditions and exceptions for valid deductions.
A

Definitions of Key Terms

  • Bad debts: Debts that are wholly or partially worthless or uncollectible, arising from money lent or income from goods/services.
  • Securities: Includes shares, bonds, debentures, notes, certificates, or other corporate/government issued indebtedness.
  • Actually ascertained to be worthless: Determined based on sound business judgment, facts, circumstances; mere doubt or difficulty collecting is insufficient.
  • Actually charged off from books: Debt must be written off and cancelled in accounting records by year-end; estimated uncollectibles do not qualify.

Requisites for Deductibility of Bad Debts

  • Indebtedness must be valid, legally demandable.
  • Must relate to taxpayer's trade, business, or profession.
  • Cannot be between related parties as defined by law.
  • Must be charged off the books by the end of taxable year.
  • Debt must be actually ascertained worthless and uncollectible as of year-end.
  • Commissioner considers evidence including collateral, debtor's financial condition, independent collection efforts.
  • Banks follow special rule: worthlessness ascertained by BSP Monetary Board.
  • Receivables from insolvent insurance or surety companies may be deducted only if officially declared closed.

Tax Benefit Rule on Recovery of Bad Debts

  • Recoveries of previously deducted bad debts must be included as gross income to the extent of prior tax benefit.
  • If no tax benefit was realized originally (e.g., business loss), subsequent recovery is considered return of capital, not income.

Treatment of Worthless Securities

  • Worthless securities held as capital assets, charged off within the taxable year, treated as loss on sale/exchange dated at year-end.
  • Taxpayer must produce clear and convincing evidence of worthlessness.
  • Banks and trust companies with deposit-taking operations excluded from this rule.

Repealing Clause

  • Revenue regulations or issuances inconsistent with these rules are repealed, amended, or modified accordingly.

Effectivity

  • Regulations effective 15 days after publication in a newspaper of general circulation.

Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster, building context before diving into full texts. AI-powered analysis, always verify critical details.