Title
Audit of BIR Assessments and Revenues EO 38
Law
Op Executive Order No. 38
Decision Date
Oct 30, 1998
President Joseph Ejercito Estrada mandates an immediate audit of the Bureau of Internal Revenue's assessments, revenues, and receipts to enhance tax collection efficiency and ensure public accountability, while establishing strict guidelines for confidentiality and audit procedures.
A

Authority and Scope of the Audit

  • The audit mandated targets the Bureau of Internal Revenue's (BIR) assessments, revenues, and receipts.
  • Records subject to audit are public records accessible upon presidential order per R.A. 8474.
  • The audit function constitutionally belongs to the Commission on Audit (COA), though full implementation is pending.
  • A public policy to conduct an audit of BIR’s tax assessments and revenues is declared desirable.

Coordination and General Procedures for Audit

  • The Department of Finance and the BIR must adopt measures and procedures for conducting the audit, coordinated with the COA.
  • The audit is a performance audit, conducted on a post-audit basis, focusing on final tax assessments.
  • Audits on disputed assessments wait for final determination by the appropriate authority.

Prohibition Against Duplicate Assessments

  • No duplicate tax assessment shall be made, except in cases of fraud or clear abuse of discretion.
  • Prior report and concurrence of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue is required before duplicate assessments.
  • Only the BIR, with Commissioner's clearance, may contact the taxpayer.

Confidentiality of Tax Information

  • COA auditors must maintain strict confidentiality of all tax information and sensitive data.
  • Disclosure of business secrets, income, operations, strategies or any confidential data is prohibited except where authorized by law.

Restrictions on Audit Procedures and Communications

  • COA auditors shall not directly contact BIR examiners under audit.
  • Audit observation memoranda or charges shall not be issued except final audit reports after preliminary discussions.
  • Final audit reports shall be submitted only to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue or designated representatives.

Confidential Distribution of Final Audit Reports

  • Only the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, the Secretary of Finance, COA Chair and Commissioners, the Office of the President, and Congress may receive the final audit report on a strictly confidential basis.
  • Disclosure otherwise requires a court order or presidential directive.

Material Basis and Restrictions in Conducting Audit

  • Audits are to be based strictly on taxpayer records in possession of the BIR or other government agencies.
  • Communication with taxpayers during audit is generally prohibited, except for confirmatory letters and checks of actual tax payments as per generally accepted auditing standards.

Effectivity and Supersession of Inconsistent Rules

  • The Executive Order takes effect immediately upon issuance.
  • Previous rules, regulations, or issuances inconsistent with this order are superseded, repealed, or modified accordingly.

Legal Consequences of Violations

  • Violations of this Executive Order or its implementing guidelines and rules will be dealt with in accordance with existing laws.

Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster, building context before diving into full texts. AI-powered analysis, always verify critical details.