Nature of Gross Receipts Tax
- Gross receipts tax applies to the entire receipts without deductions, exemptions, or exclusions unless explicitly stated by law.
- The tax base includes all income components such as interest in full amount.
Definition and Treatment of Interest Income
- Interest is the full amount paid by the borrower for the use of money lent, without deductions.
- Revenue Regulations define interest as the amount paid on savings and time deposits, allowing no deductions.
- The total interest income earned by a lending bank includes the gross amount before any withholding tax.
Example of Interest Income and Final Withholding Tax
- If interest income is P100, the lending bank’s gross receipts include the full P100.
- The depository bank withholds 20% final tax amounting to P20 and remits it to the government.
- The lending bank physically receives P80 (net), but the full P100 is considered gross receipts for taxation.
Concept of Constructive Receipt
- Receipt of interest income includes both physical and constructive receipt.
- Constructive receipt occurs when the depository bank withholds the tax before remitting it to the government.
- Both the net amount received and the withheld tax portion constitute the actual income of the lending bank.
Relation of Withholding Tax to Gross Receipts
- The withholding tax amount is part of the gross receipts because it represents income earned, transferred to the government as tax payment.
- The gross receipts tax is levied on the total interest income, not on the final withholding tax itself.
Legal Interpretation and Legislative Intent
- The law would explicitly exclude any tax amount from gross receipts if intended by the legislature.
- Since there is no such exclusion for the final withholding tax here, it remains part of gross receipts.
Conclusion and Effect of Supreme Court Decision
- China Banking Corporation cannot exclude the amount withheld as final tax from its taxable gross receipts.
- The Supreme Court denied CBC’s petition and granted the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s petition.
- Decisions from the Court of Tax Appeals and Court of Appeals overturning this BIR position were set aside.
Instruction to Revenue Officers
- The directive enjoins all internal revenue officers to widely publicize this clarification.