Title
BIR Rules on VAT Refund Claims Audit
Law
Bir Revenue Audit Memorandum Order No. 1-91
Decision Date
Jan 11, 1991
BIR Revenue Audit Memorandum Order No. 1-91 establishes guidelines for auditing claims for VAT refunds from zero-rated transactions, requiring claimants to settle any outstanding accounts before receiving tax credit certificates and outlining specific audit procedures to ensure compliance and accuracy in reporting.
A

Administrative Policies

  • Every audit requires a Letter of Authority (LA).
  • Claimants must settle outstanding delinquent accounts before issuance of refund/TCC.
    • Separate TCC for delinquent accounts can be issued for payment only, with excess refunded.
    • Protests on delinquent accounts processed if compliant with Revenue Regulations No. 12-85.
  • Deficiency findings on taxes other than VAT from the LA are referred to appropriate audit offices.
  • Processing period for refund claims starts on submission of the last required document.
  • Issued Tax Credit Certificates may be used against any direct internal revenue tax liabilities.

Audit Objectives and Pre-Audit Steps

  • Objective: Verify refundable/creditable VAT input tax on zero-rated transactions.
  • Pre-audit requires understanding the taxpayer’s business structure, economic activity, accounting systems, and prior audit findings.
  • Export sales by non-VAT taxpayers treated as VAT exempt.
  • Prior approval is mandatory for zero-rating under special laws or international agreements.
  • Claims must be filed within two years from the relevant transaction date.

Audit of Sales and Output Tax

  • Reconcile sales per VAT returns with subsidiary ledgers and refund applications; discrepancies must be clarified.
  • Sales classifications must align with NIRC sections; "deemed sales" include transfers or uses outside business courses.
  • Zero-rated sales must correspond to exports, foreign currency sales, or qualifying transactions with supporting documents.
  • Export proceeds must be inwardly remitted and certified by the Central Bank.
  • Foreign currency sales and zero-rated services require verification of buyer status, payment, and remittance.
  • Constructive inward remittance requires Central Bank approval and certified offsetting.
  • Effectively zero-rated transactions require approved applications with valid dates.
  • Accounts related to sales and income must be analyzed and reconciled with sales figures.
  • Detailed pro-forma computations provided for gross sales and receipts.

Audit Checks on Invoicing and Accounting

  • Verify all sales journal entries against invoices; check for compliance with VAT invoice requirements.
  • Monitor authorization to print invoices and use cash registers; detect unauthorized or duplicated invoices.
  • Validate that proper VAT invoices are used for taxable transactions; exempt or zero-rated sales invoices must be properly indicated.
  • Ensure VAT is billed correctly; use prescribed factors to compute output tax when incorrectly invoiced.
  • For taxpayers with partial VAT exemptions, adjust computations accordingly.
  • Confirm whether other charges are included in the gross taxable sales.
  • For sales of services, verify advance payments and material components per contract terms.
  • Investigate under-declaration through abnormal account behaviors and cross-check customer/supplier records.

Audit of Purchases and Input Tax

  • Reconcile purchases per VAT returns with subsidiary purchase journals.
  • Confirm no input tax credit arises from non-VAT/exempt sellers or personal purchases.
  • Validate proper documentation, including VAT invoices and import entry documents for importation.
  • Ensure purchase returns reduce input tax credits appropriately.
  • Adjust input tax credits for taxpayers with partial exemptions proportionate to sales.
  • Allocate input tax between taxable and exempt activities when applicable.
  • Check consistency of input tax carryover balances in returns and accounting records.
  • Presumptive and deemed-paid input taxes are not refundable or creditable.

Cancellation of Original Purchase Invoices/Receipts

  • Upon claim approval and before TCC issuance or refund disbursement, source documents of allowed/disallowed input taxes must be cancelled with a cancellation stamp.

Reporting Requirements

  • Audit reports must be concise, complete and include:
    • Letter of Authority, VAT returns, worksheets of schedules (zero-rated sales, purchases, adjustments, disallowances).
    • Computations of allowable input tax, deficiency VAT, and other taxes.
    • Revenue official’s memorandum report and authority to issue credit or refund.
    • Supporting documents including application forms, approvals, certificates, bank statements, and taxpayer certificates.
  • Strict compliance with prescribed checklist of procedures and documentations is required.

Checklist of Requirements for Filing VAT Credit/Refund Claims

  • Three copies of VAT Credit/Refund Application (Form 2552).
  • Approved zero-rate application for effectively zero-rated sales.
  • Photocopies of VAT purchase invoices and official receipts arranged with corresponding summaries.
  • VAT returns evidencing input tax credit not applied to output tax.
  • Taxpayer certificates detailing sales categorization.
  • Statements from regulating agencies where applicable.
  • Authorization to maintain a special dollar account where necessary.
  • Additional supporting documents like articles of incorporation, contracts, inventory, BOI registration, and audited financial statements.
  • For constructive remittance: Central Bank approval, monthly offsetting schedules, certifications, and clearance.

Specific Documentary Requirements for Different Types of Sales

  1. Export Sales:
  • Export sales summary with details (dates, buyers, invoice numbers, shipment details, foreign currency values, remittance details).
  • Export documents and certificates from banks confirming inward remittance.
  1. Zero-Rated Sales or Services:
  • Contract agreements and payment evidences.
  • Receipts, billing summaries, and bank remittance certificates.
  • Special reports for manning services regarding foreign receipts.
  1. Effectively Zero-Rated Sales:
  • Invoice summaries, sales evidence, billing reconciliation, and proof of actual delivery.
  • Additional mining company requirements.
  1. Purchase of Capital Goods:
  • Original invoices and VAT payment confirmations.
  • Importation documents and customs receipts for imported capital goods.

Strict adherence to these provisions ensures proper audit, verification, and processing of VAT credit and refund claims relating to zero-rated transactions and capital goods purchases.


Analyze Cases Smarter, Faster
Jur helps you analyze cases smarter to comprehend faster, building context before diving into full texts. AI-powered analysis, always verify critical details.