Law Summary
Classification and Composition of Courts-Martial
- There are three kinds of courts-martial: General, Special, and Summary.
- General courts-martial must have at least five officers, Special courts-martial at least three, and Summary courts-martial consist of one officer.
- Members of courts-martial are appointed among officers on active duty, preferably those with adequate service, experience, and judicial temperament.
Appointment and Authority of Courts-Martial
- Different authorities prescribe who may appoint each kind of court-martial, with safeguards to avoid conflicts of interest.
- General courts-martial require inclusion of a law member from the Judge Advocate Service or another qualified officer.
- Trial judge advocates and defense counsel must be appointed for general and special courts-martial to ensure prosecution and defense rights.
Jurisdiction of Courts-Martial
- General courts-martial may try any person subject to military law for any offense, including under laws of war.
- Special courts-martial try non-capital offenses with limitations on punishment severity.
- Summary courts-martial try minor offenses, excluding officers and certain cadet ranks, with limited punitive power.
- Concurrent jurisdiction is recognized; other military tribunals may try offenses subject to their authority.
Trial Procedures and Rights
- The trial judge advocate prosecutes and the accused has the right to counsel, including civil counsel if available.
- Challenges to court members are allowed for cause, ballots for findings and sentences are secret and governed by specific rules.
- Various oaths are required for court members, advocates, witnesses, reporters, and interpreters to uphold impartiality and truthfulness.
- Continuances may be granted for reasonable causes.
- The accused may be tried as if pleading not guilty when refusing or failing to plead properly.
- Courts have power to compel witness attendance and testimony; refusal by non-military witnesses is punishable as contempt.
- Self-incrimination is prohibited; witnesses need not answer irrelevant or degrading questions.
- Depositions and records of courts of inquiry may be used as evidence under specified conditions.
- Courts announce acquittals publicly; closed sessions restrict presence of advocates.
Records and Reviews
- Detailed records of proceedings must be kept by all courts-martial and authenticated.
- Records are forwarded to the convening authority and eventually to the Judge Advocate General.
- Errors in procedure or evidence do not invalidate trials unless substantial rights of the accused are harmed.
- The President may prescribe procedural rules aligning with recognized rules of evidence when practicable.
Limitations on Prosecution
- Statute of limitations generally is two years, three years for desertion in peace and certain offenses; excludes periods when the accused is absent or not amenable to military justice.
- Double jeopardy is prohibited unless a prior finding is not final, and limits are placed on retrials and sentence increases.
Punishments and Sentencing
- Cruel and unusual punishments are prohibited.
- Confinement in penitentiaries is limited to specific instances and durations.
- Death sentence requires unanimity of the court for capital offenses; other serious sentences require qualified majorities.
- Publication of punishments for cowardice or fraud is mandated; associates may face social sanction.
- Punishments have maximum limits set by the President.
Approval, Confirmation, and Review of Sentences
- No court-martial sentence may be executed without approval by the appointing authority.
- The President’s confirmation is required for sentences affecting general officers, dismissals of officers, cadets’ dismissal, and death sentences except under wartime exceptions.
- Approving and confirming authorities have powers to modify findings and sentences, including reducing offenses or sentences.
- A Board of Review under the Judge Advocate General examines records before submission to the President and may recommend rehearing or modification based on sufficiency and legality.
- Execution of sentences may be suspended or mitigated; restoration to duty is possible during suspension.
- The death or honorable discharge of a person under suspension extinguishes unexecuted parts of the sentence.
Specific Military Offenses
- The law details punitive articles covering fraudulent enlistment, false muster, desertion, disrespect, insubordination, mutiny, assaulting officers, and failure to suppress mutiny.
- Severe penalties including death or dismissal apply to serious offenses like desertion in wartime, mutiny, sedition, and spying.
- Other offenses include misconduct such as intoxication on duty, disorderly conduct, misuse of military property, dueling, and crimes under penal laws committed on military reservations.
Courts of Inquiry
- Courts of Inquiry may be ordered to investigate any accusation or transaction involving officers or soldiers.
- They consist of three or more officers, and the party investigated may be represented by counsel.
- Powers include summoning and examining witnesses, with testimony under oath similar to courts-martial.
- Courts of inquiry keep authenticated records and generally do not express opinions on the merits unless specifically ordered.
Miscellaneous Provisions
- Commanding officers may impose minor disciplinary punishments without court-martial unless requested by the accused.
- Procedures are established for redress of property damage caused by military personnel.
- Civil authorities may arrest deserters and deliver them to military custody.
- Soldiers are liable to serve additional time to compensate for deserts, absence without leave, or confinement resulting from misconduct.
- Discharge of enlisted men requires proper certification; officers require Presidential order or court-martial sentence.
- Oaths of enlistment and the reading of fundamental articles are mandated at enlistment and periodically thereafter.
- Rights to copies of trial records, investigations of suspicious deaths, and administration of oaths are provided.
- The law establishes authority for appointment of court reporters and interpreters, and defines roles of assistant legal officers.
- Command and rank precedence in combined commands are governed by Presidential authority.
- Complaints of wrongs against commanding officers may be escalated to higher military authority, with reports to Army Headquarters.
Repeal and Implementation
- Offenses committed prior to this Act’s effective date are governed by prior laws.
- Laws inconsistent with this Act are repealed.
- The Act takes effect upon approval.