Case Summary (G.R. No. 169942)
Facts of the Case
Petitioners Fonacier and Yabes served as the editor and managing editor of the Philippine Social Sciences and Humanities Review, which is dedicated to scholarly work in the social sciences and humanities. This publication is not intended for widespread public distribution; instead, it is primarily circulated within the University of the Philippines and select academic institutions abroad. During the University’s Golden Jubilee in July 1959, the contentious article was published. Subsequently, on June 7, 1961, a complaint was lodged against them by Carlos Albert, alleging incitement to sedition under Article 142 of the Revised Penal Code. Following a preliminary investigation initiated by the City Fiscal, there were impending threats to file formal charges against the petitioners.
Legal Issues Presented
The primary issue for determination is whether the City Fiscal should be enjoined from filing criminal charges against the petitioners for publishing the aforementioned article. The petitioners contended that the potential legal action constitutes harassment and a misuse of public power, infringing upon their academic freedom guaranteed by the Constitution.
Court's Analysis on Criminal Prosecution
The court identified that it is within the respondent City Fiscal's duty to investigate complaints of criminal offenses and file appropriate charges when warranted by the evidence. A guiding principle established in jurisprudence dictates that injunctions or writs of prohibition are typically not available to inhibit criminal prosecutions unless it poses an affront to orderly justice or is exploited in a vindictive manner.
Conclusion on the Injunction Request
Upon reviewing the allegations and the context of the case, the court found no sufficie
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 169942)
Case Overview
- The case involves an original petition filed by petitioners Tomas S. Fonacier and Leopoldo Y. Yabes against the City Fiscal of Quezon City.
- The petition seeks to restrain, prohibit, and enjoin the City Fiscal and his assistants from filing criminal information and prosecuting the petitioners for acts related to the publication of an article in the Golden Jubilee issue of the Philippine Social Sciences and Humanities Review.
- The specific article in question is titled "The Peasant War in the Philippines: A Study of the Causes of Social Unrest in the Philippines and An Analysis of the Philippine Political Economy."
Background of the Petitioners
- Tomas S. Fonacier serves as the editor, while Leopoldo Y. Yabes is the managing editor of the Philippine Social Sciences and Humanities Review.
- The Review is an academic publication that focuses on recent scholarly papers and monographs in the Social Sciences and Humanities, particularly those related to research conducted at the University of the Philippines.
- The publication is not widely distributed to the public but is primarily confined to the University of the Philippines and its correspondent universities and libraries abroad, with only a limited number of copies occasionally sold to private researchers.
- For the Golden Jubilee of the University of the Philippines, 2,000 copies of t