Case Summary (G.R. No. 15635)
Incident and Conflict Background
Melecio de Vera and his laborers were gathering tobacco on the disputed land when they heard horn signals, followed by more than thirteen men, identified as Jose Bengzon’s tenants, coming towards them. The men surrounded and attacked de Vera’s group, resulting in wounds sustained by laborers Luis Moyalde and Fernando Ferrer. When the aggressors saw the wounded men, one of them signaled retreat by sounding a horn, after which they withdrew.
Legal Proceedings Prior to the Incident
Jose Bengzon had obtained from the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan a preliminary injunction in October 1916 to prevent Melecio de Vera and his workers from disturbing Bengzon and his tenants during the palay harvest on the land. However, this injunction was later dissolved after de Vera provided an obligation with sureties to compensate any damages Bengzon might suffer. Despite notification of the injunction's dissolution, Bengzon and his tenants refused to allow de Vera to enter the property, leading to accusations of contempt against Bengzon, Fulgencio Tandoc, Jose Corpus, and Alberto Campanero.
The Attack and its Aftermath
On the date in question, the group of Bengzon’s men, led by Fulgencio Tandoc, attacked de Vera and his workers. Luis Moyalde was struck on the head by Tandoc with a bamboo stick, and subsequently attacked further by Jose Corpus, Luis de Vera, and Bernardino Ruiz. Moyalde died later that day due to the injuries sustained. The legal information filed concerned only the death of Moyalde, and fourteen men were charged as perpetrators; one accused, Domingo Galvez, died before the trial.
Trial Court’s Judgment
The court convicted Fulgencio Tandoc, Luis de Vera, and Bernardino Ruiz, sentencing them to four years’ imprisonment, accessory penalties, payment of indemnity of P1,000 jointly and severally to Moyalde’s heirs, and shared costs. The rest of the accused were acquitted.
Appellate Review and Legal Analysis
Upon review, the court found the trial court’s classification of the crime as homicide committed in a tumultuous affray to be erroneous. A tumultuous affray presupposes a chaotic fight among several persons where the specific author of any injury or death cannot be identified. In this case, however, the aggression was deliberate and ordered, with known participants and clear unity of purpose. The attackers had rallied under horn signals, conducted the assault in an organized manner, and cooperated in inflicting fatal injuries on Moyalde.
Conclusion on the Nature of the Crime
The court held that the attack constituted the crime of homicide rather than a mere tumultuous affray because the responsible offenders were known and acted with a common purpose. Furthermore, the court applied the aggravating circumstance of abuse of superior strength
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 15635)
Facts of the Case
- On or about January 7, 1917, Melecio de Vera was in charge of gathering tobacco on Victorino Navarro’s land in the barrio of San Jose, municipality of Urdaneta, Pangasinan.
- Melecio de Vera was assisted by several laborers: Lorenzo de Vera, Luis Moyalde, Celestino Para-an, and Fernando Ferrer during the work.
- While working, the group heard the sound of a horn twice, signaling the approach of more than thirteen men from the eastern side of the land.
- These men, led by Fulgencio Tandoc, surrounded and attacked Melecio de Vera and his laborers.
- During this attack, Luis Moyalde and Fernando Ferrer were wounded.
- Upon seeing the wounded men lying on the ground covered with blood, Jose Corpus, one of the aggressors, sounded a horn and the group of attackers withdrew.
- The land where the incident took place was claimed by Jose Bengzon, who had earlier obtained from the Court of First Instance of Pangasinan a preliminary injunction preventing Melecio de Vera and his agents from disturbing Bengzon or his tenants during the harvest of palay growing on the land.
- This injunction was later dissolved after Melecio de Vera gave a bond with sureties to answer for any damages Jose Bengzon might suffer.
- Despite the dissolution of the injunction and notification thereof, Jose Bengzon and his tenants did not allow Melecio de Vera and his workers to enter the land.
- Melecio de Vera accused Jose Bengzon and his tenants of contempt, prompting a court order requiring Bengzon, Fulgencio Tandoc, Jose Corpus, and Alberto Campanero to appear and show cause why they should not be punished for contempt.
- On the day of the attack, Luis Moyalde was struck on the head by Fulgencio Tandoc with a bamboo stick and fell to the ground.
- While Luis Moyalde was down, Luis de Vera, Jose Corpus, and Bernardino Ruiz also delivered blows to him with clubs and canes.
- Luis Moyalde died the same evening due to the injuries sustained, the most serious being the one delivered by Fulgencio Tandoc.
- The information in the case relates exclusively to the death of Luis Moyalde.
- Fourteen men, incl