Case Summary (G.R. No. L-47405)
Background of the Case
The controversy arises from the local elections held in May 2004, wherein Israel and Jaberael contested their respective positions for mayor and vice mayor in South Upi, Maguindanao. A pre-election complaint was filed by Israel to disqualify Antonio B. Gunsi, Sr. from running for mayor, which led to multiple proclamations by the Municipal Board of Canvassers that were ultimately annulled by the COMELEC for being based on incomplete canvass results.
Relevant Proceedings and Orders
Following the annulments, the COMELEC directed the SBOC to reconvene for a re-canvass of the election returns but faced complications. Notably, when counting ballots from four precincts, contested ballots emerged, which were subject to inquiry as they potentially affected the election results. In a subsequent order, the COMELEC en banc directed the SBOC to proclaim Abdullah Campong for vice-mayor and referenced the matter of mayoral succession to the Department of Interior and Local Government due to Gunsi's disqualification.
Petitioner’s Motions and Issues Raised
The Sinsuats filed multiple motions to suspend the SBOC's actions, which the COMELEC denied. The crux of their argument rests on whether the contested ballots, which had been tampered, should be counted for Jaberael and whether Israel should be declared the duly elected mayor based on Gunsi's disqualification.
Legal Issues Presented
The main issues presented before the Supreme Court involve whether the COMELEC committed grave abuse of discretion by not counting the contested ballots and whether Israel should be proclaimed mayor considering the finality of Gunsi's disqualification before an official proclamation of a winning candidate. Additionally, respondents argued that the matter became moot as Campong had assumed office.
Decision on the First Issue
The Supreme Court ruled that the COMELEC did not gravely abuse its discretion by failing to consider the contested ballots as votes for Jaberael. The court clarified that issues regarding ballot appreciation fall within the purview of election protests, which were not suitable for resolution in a pre-proclamation controversy. The specific ballots challenged were inappropriately scrutinized at the pre-proclamation stage, which is explicitly limited to procedural questions, rendering the SBOC's initial actions sufficient.
Decision on the Second Issue
Regarding the proclamation of Israel as mayor, the Supreme Court upheld that the COMELEC cannot award the mayoral position to the candidate with the second highest votes when the primary candidate (Gunsi, who obtained the highest number of votes) is disqualified. The rationa
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. L-47405)
Case Overview
- This case involves a petition for certiorari and prohibition with an application for a temporary restraining order filed by petitioners Datu Israel C. Sinsuat and Datu Jaberael R. Sinsuat against the Commission on Elections (COMELEC) and the Special Municipal Board of Canvassers (SBOC) of South Upi, Maguindanao.
- The primary issue is the denial of their motions to suspend the reconvening of the SBOC and the proclamation of winning candidates due to alleged irregularities in the election process.
Background Facts
- Datu Israel C. Sinsuat was a mayoralty candidate, and Datu Jaberael R. Sinsuat was a vice mayoralty candidate in the May 2004 Local Elections in South Upi, Maguindanao.
- Israel filed a complaint (SPA No. 04-202) for the cancellation of the certificate of candidacy of Antonio B. Gunsi, Sr.
- After the election, multiple proclamations were made for mayor, vice-mayor, and councilors, leading to confusion and subsequent annulments by the COMELEC due to incomplete canvassing.
Procedural History
- The COMELEC First Division annulled the proclamations due to incomplete canvassing and ordered the appointment of the SBOC to re-canvass all election returns.
- The SBOC was directed to act as Special Board of Election Inspectors for four precincts, leading to the submission of election results on May 16, 2005.
- The SBOC reported discrepancies, particularly concerning 95 contested ballots from Precincts 15A and 17A.