Case Summary (A.M. No. RTJ-17-2486)
Factual Background
The administrative complaint alleged that Judge Abul demanded large amounts of money ranging from P200,000.00 to P300,000.00 from detainees at the Provincial Jail of Agusan, in exchange for their release from prison or for the dismissal of their criminal cases. The Supreme Court noted that the OCA investigation began upon receipt of the exposure letter by Rev. Father Saniel, and that during the investigation the OCA confirmed that Judge Abul indeed engaged in extortion activities, which the OCA characterized as grave misconduct constituting violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct. The OCA then recommended a monetary penalty of P500,000.00, to be deducted from Judge Abul’s retirement gratuity.
While the administrative case was still under review by the Court, Judge Abul died in an ambush on August 5, 2017. His death occurred before the Supreme Court had finally resolved the administrative complaint.
The September 3, 2019 Administrative Liability Ruling
In the September 3, 2019 Per Curiam en banc decision, the Court’s Majority held that there were sufficient grounds to find Judge Abul administratively liable for Misconduct, described as grave misconduct. Importantly, the Majority ruled that Judge Abul’s death prior to resolution did not require the dismissal of the complaint, especially where the administrative process had already afforded him due process during the investigation stage and where the Court’s jurisdiction was deemed to survive his death.
The Court also recognized that grave misconduct is punishable by dismissal from service and carries consequences such as forfeiture of benefits and perpetual disqualification from reappointment or appointment to public office. However, because Judge Abul had died, the Majority imposed only an accessory penalty: the forfeiture of all retirement and allied benefits except accrued leaves, treating the death as a bar to the imposition of dismissal but not to the imposition of forfeiture as a consequence.
Motion for Reconsideration and the Core Controversy
After the September 3, 2019 decision, Bernadita C. Abul filed a Motion for Reconsideration addressing, among others, survivorship and related benefits. The Motion pressed that the administrative case should not have proceeded to findings of guilt and sanctions because Judge Abul was already dead and could no longer contest the ruling or protect his rights after the Court’s decision.
The Motion triggered the Court’s reassessment of earlier pronouncements that death during the pendency of an administrative case does not automatically cause dismissal, and that administrative proceedings may continue notwithstanding cessation from public service. The question therefore centered on whether continuing the administrative adjudication and imposing sanctions after death violated constitutional rights, and whether survivorship benefits should be released to the heirs.
Decision to Grant the Motion for Reconsideration
The Court, in the September 8, 2020 Resolution, granted the Motion for Reconsideration. The Court reversed and set aside its September 3, 2019 decision. It dismissed the administrative complaint against the late Judge Abul and ordered that corresponding death and survivorship benefits be released to his heirs.
The Court’s shift was anchored on constitutional precepts, particularly the constitutional rights to presumption of innocence and due process, and on an assimilation of criminal and administrative principles where the respondent dies before final judgment. The Court explicitly treated its prior approach—allowing continuance of proceedings and imposing forfeiture despite death—as incorrect under this constitutional lens.
Legal Basis and Reasoning
The Court reasoned that the death of a respondent in an administrative case before final resolution was a cause for dismissal. Otherwise, the Court held, the failure to dismiss would transgress constitutional rights to due process and presumption of innocence.
The Court drew an analogy to criminal proceedings where an accused’s death after conviction but pending appeal results in dismissal. It explained that the criminal rule is triggered by the accused’s right to presumption of innocence and due process under the Constitution. Because those principles are instrumental in both criminal and civil contexts, the Court held that they should also apply to administrative proceedings, despite the different quantum of proof. The Court treated the standard for administrative proceedings—substantial evidence—as lower, and therefore held that the dismissal rule should similarly follow upon death before final resolution.
The Court then articulated four grounds supporting dismissal.
First, it invoked presumption of innocence. It cited Article III, Section 14 of the 1987 Constitution, which provides that in all criminal prosecutions the accused is presumed innocent until the contrary is proved. The Court held that even in administrative cases, where only substantial evidence is required, a respondent should still be presumed innocent when death precedes final judgment, because the respondent could no longer submit additional evidence to support a position.
Second, it treated the logic of extinguishment of liability upon death. It cited Article 89(1) of the Revised Penal Code, emphasizing that criminal liability is totally extinguished by death, and as to pecuniary penalties liability is extinguished when death occurs before final judgment. The Court reasoned that if liability is extinguished in criminal cases based on the timing of death relative to final judgment, then administrative cases—where the quantum of proof is only substantial evidence—should adopt a similar principle rather than impose more rigid punitive consequences.
Third, it grounded dismissal on due process. It held that due process encompasses the entire proceedings, from investigation to finality of judgment. It stated that due process in administrative cases requires an opportunity to be heard, and that the essence of due process is to be heard and, in administrative proceedings, to have an opportunity to explain one’s side and to seek reconsideration. Because a deceased respondent cannot participate after death, the Court held that continuing the administrative adjudication after death constitutes a denial of due process.
Fourth, it invoked humanitarian reasons and equitable considerations in favor of the heirs. The Court held that the case should be dismissed and death and survivorship benefits should be released, especially where death occurred before any final judgment and no definitive penalty was finally imposed before death.
Application to Judge Abul and Treatment of Death Benefits
On the humanitarian and equitable considerations, the Court relied on the circumstances of Judge Abul’s death and the position of the surviving spouse. It noted that Bernadita wrote the Court a letter dated September 13, 2017, describing herself as a housemaker without any other source of income. She asserted that after Judge Abul’s preventive suspension, the family faced financial difficulties and she requested the release of accrued leave benefits and other assistance to meet daily needs and to fund her son’s medical education.
The Court also considered that Judge Abul was murdered only days after turning sixty-eight years old. It treated this timing as significant because he would have reached the compulsory retirement age of seventy (70) for judges before the Court’s September 3, 2019 Per Curiam decision, had he not died.
The Court emphasized that the mistakes attributed to Judge Abul should not punish his heirs who had no part in or knowledge of the alleged extortion. It held that Judge Abul’s liability was personal and extinguished upon his death, and that the imposition of forfeiture would effectively inflict a harsh penalty on innocent family members. The Court thus found it proper, upon reconsideration, to dismiss the administrative complaint and release the death and survivorship benefits.
Statutory and Regulatory Basis for Release of Benefits
In ordering the release of benefits, the Court referred to Sections 2 to 3-A of Republic Act No. 9946, which grant additional retirement, survivorship, and other benefits to members of the judiciary, including benefits to heirs when a judge dies while in actu
...continue reading
Case Syllabus (A.M. No. RTJ-17-2486)
- The case stemmed from a complaint alleging that Presiding Judge Godofredo B. Abul, Jr. of Branch 4, Regional Trial Court, Butuan City, Agusan del Norte committed extortion by demanding money from detainees in exchange for their release or the dismissal of their criminal cases.
- The Office of the Court Administrator (OCA) investigated the allegations and recommended a monetary penalty to be deducted from the respondent judge’s retirement gratuity.
- While the administrative matter was pending before the Court, Judge Abul died on August 5, 2017, during the pendency of the case.
- The Court initially issued a Per Curiam September 3, 2019 decision that found administrative liability and imposed an accessory forfeiture of retirement-related benefits.
- The surviving spouse, Bernadita C. Abul, filed a Motion for Reconsideration, challenging the continuing effect of the administrative case after Judge Abul’s death.
- The Court resolved the Motion for Reconsideration by reversing its September 3, 2019 ruling, dismissing the administrative complaint, and directing the release of death and survivorship benefits to Judge Abul’s heirs.
- Several Justices concurred with the dismissal but expressed separate views on the doctrinal basis, particularly on whether the death of a respondent in an administrative case should automatically require dismissal.
Parties and Procedural Posture
- The complainant was identified in the record as Rev. Father Antoni A. Saniel, Director of the Prison Ministry of the Diocese of Butuan, who exposed the alleged extortion activities.
- The respondent in the administrative complaint was Presiding Judge Godofredo B. Abul, Jr. of RTC Branch 4, Butuan City.
- The administrative body was the OCA, which conducted an investigation and submitted a report and recommendation.
- The reviewing authority was the Court, sitting En Banc, acting on a Per Curiam decision dated September 3, 2019.
- The procedural trigger for reconsideration was the Motion for Reconsideration filed by the respondent judge’s surviving spouse Bernadita C. Abul.
- The Court later resolved the Motion for Reconsideration on September 8, 2020, reversing and setting aside the September 3, 2019 decision.
- The disposition dismissed the administrative complaint against the late Judge Abul and ordered the release of corresponding death and survivorship benefits to his heirs.
Key Factual Allegations
- The complaint alleged that Judge Abul extorted large amounts ranging from P200,000.00 to P300,000.00 from detainees of the Provincial Jail of Agusan.
- The alleged consideration was the detainees’ release from prison or the dismissal of their criminal cases.
- The OCA’s investigation confirmed that Judge Abul engaged in extortion activities.
- The OCA characterized the conduct as grave misconduct constituting a violation of the Code of Judicial Conduct.
- While the administrative review was pending, Judge Abul was killed by an unidentified motorcycle-riding shooter on August 5, 2017 at 68 years old.
- The record showed that Judge Abul’s spouse survived the ambush and was also wounded.
- The spouse later informed the Court of Judge Abul’s death through a letter dated September 13, 2017, and described their family’s financial difficulties following the preventive suspension and during the pending proceedings.
OCA Findings and Recommendation
- The OCA investigated after receiving the complaint letter from Rev. Father Antoni A. Saniel.
- The OCA found sufficient factual basis to conclude that Judge Abul engaged in extortion from detainees in exchange for case disposition favors.
- The OCA concluded that the extortion constituted grave misconduct, a serious judicial offense.
- The OCA recommended that Judge Abul be fined P500,000.00, with the fine to be deducted from his retirement gratuity.
- The OCA’s report formed the factual foundation later adopted by the Court in its September 3, 2019 decision, subject to modification of the penalty.
September 3, 2019 Per Curiam Decision
- The Court, by Majority vote, found sufficient grounds to hold Judge Abul administratively liable for Misconduct.
- The Court ruled that Judge Abul’s death before the resolution did not warrant dismissal where the investigation stage had already been completed and the Court’s jurisdiction survived the death.
- The Court emphasized that grave misconduct is punishable with dismissal from service, forfeiture of all or part of benefits, and perpetual disqualification from government office, including government-owned and controlled corporations, except accrued leave credits.
- The Court imposed an accessory penalty given the respondent’s death by ordering forfeiture of all retirement and allied benefits, except accrued leaves.
- The September 3, 2019 decision thereby converted the consequence of grave misconduct into forfeiture in light of the inability to impose dismissal once death had occurred.
Motion for Reconsideration Grounds
- The Motion for Reconsideration was filed by the surviving spouse Bernadita C. Abul.
- The Motion argued that Judge Abul’s death preceded the final resolution and prevented him from assailing findings, maintaining his innocence, and expressing remorse through further proceedings.
- The Motion also urged humanitarian considerations to mitigate the forfeiture imposed despite the death.
- The request implicitly challenged the continuation of the administrative case into the stage of final adjudication and the effect of death on survivorship and forfeiture consequences.
Constitutional and Doctrinal Framework
- The Court treated administrative disciplinary proceedings as constrained by constitutional guarantees, particularly due process and the presumption of innocence.
- The Court invoked Art. III, Sec. 1, 1987 Constitution on the right not to be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law, as discussed in the concurring separate opinion.
- The Court relied on Article 3, Section 14 of the 1987 Constitution stating that in criminal prosecutions the accused shall be presumed innocent until the contrary is proved.
- The Court reasoned that although administrative cases require only substantial evidence, the respondent should still be presumed innocent when death occurred before final judgment.
- The Court applied the logic of criminal liability extinguishment by death, citing Article 89(1) of the Revised Penal Code, to support extinguishment of punitive consequences in administrative proceedings when death occurs before final adjudication.
- The Court acknowledged an earlier doctrinal approach that allowed non-dismissal in administrative cases based on public policy that public office is a public trust and jurisdiction survives cessation from office.
- The Court also referenced jurisprudence recognizing exceptions to the general rule that death does not automatically dismiss an administrative case.
Court’s Reasoning for Reversal
- The Court revisited its earlier pronouncement that death pending resolution does not automatically terminate an administrative proceeding.
- The Court held that the presumption of innocence and due process concerns require dismissal when death occurs before final judgment.
- The Court declared that non-dismissal after the respondent’s death would violate constitutional rights to due process and presumption of innocence.
- The Court framed the issue as analogous to criminal cases where death during appeal leads to dismissal due to the operation of the presumption of innocence and due process rights.
- The Court stated that the quantum of proof in administrative proceedings is substantial evidence, yet the lower standard did not negate the constitutional presumption where finality had not been reached.
- The Court further reasoned that death prevented the respondent from participating in proceedings after the final judgment stage, including the ability to seek reconsideration or clemency.