Case Summary (G.R. No. 209479)
Relevant Facts and Incident Details
On December 9, 1962, the Degamo brothers were fatally shot and subsequently stabbed by the appellants. The incident occurred after a series of conflicts over a riceland that the Llameras had unlawfully occupied, which led to previous legal actions initiated by the Degamo family for their repossession. Witnesses provided critical accounts of the attack, detailing how Coleto Llamera shot the Degamo brothers from the window of a house, while Tomas and Gerardo Llamera approached to inflict additional harm with bolos.
Law and Charges
The appellants were charged with multiple counts of murder under the Revised Penal Code of the Philippines, with aggravating circumstances considered. The trial court initially convicted all appellants, sentencing Tomas, Gerardo, and Coleto Llamera to reclusion perpetua, while Rubencio Llorca's involvement was also scrutinized.
Death of Coleto Llamera
During the pendency of the appeal, Coleto Llamera passed away in prison due to enteritis on October 19, 1972, leading to the dismissal of the case against him in relation to his criminal liability.
Trial Proceedings
The trial court conducted a joint trial for the accused. Following the prosecution's presentation of the evidence, the case against Romualda Llorca was dismissed. The detailed testimonies from both the prosecution and the defense shaped the trial outcome, portraying a sequence of events marked by conflict, aggression, and fatal consequences.
Defense Arguments
The defense contended that the deaths resulted from a mutual fight initiated by the Degamo brothers, arguing mitigating circumstances for Tomas and Gerardo Llamera, including voluntary surrender. The defense also asserted that Rubencio Llorca should not be liable as there was no evidence of his direct participation or conspiracy with the other appellants.
Prosecution Evidence
The prosecution presented substantial evidence, including eyewitness accounts and medical examinations, which established that the victims suffered both gunshot and stab wounds. The medical examination disclosed the precise causes of death and corroborated eyewitness accounts about the nature of the attack.
Outcome of the Appeal
The appellate court scrutinized the evidence and the claims made by the defense. The court held that the killing exhibited treachery due to the surprise attack on the victims. It distinguished the roles of the appellants, affirming that Tomas and Gerardo Llamera directly participated in the commission of the murders while questioning Rubencio Llorca's involvement.
Final Rulings and Sentencing
The conviction of Tomas and Gerardo Llam
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 209479)
Case Overview
- The case is an appeal from the judgment of the Court of First Instance of Surigao convicting the appellants Tomas Llamera, Gerardo Llamera, Coleto Llamera, and Rubencio Llorca of the crime of murder.
- The appellants were charged with the killings of Celso Degamo, Manuel Degamo, and Egenio Degamo and were sentenced to reclusion perpetua, along with indemnification of the victims' heirs.
- The case was brought to the Supreme Court following the trial court's decision and the subsequent appeal by the defendants.
Background of the Case
- The conflict between the parties stemmed from a dispute over a piece of riceland in Sitio Dapia, Albor, Surigao del Norte, with the Degamo brothers having previously filed an ejectment case against Tomas Llamera.
- The Degamos sought to reclaim the riceland, and tensions escalated when the Llameras plowed another portion of the Degamos' land shortly before the incident.
Incident Description
- On December 9, 1962, the Degamo brothers were ambushed after leaving their ricefields. Witnesses reported seeing Coleto Llamera firing a gun from a window, resulting in Egenio falling to the ground followed by Celso and Manuel being shot.
- Following the gunfire, Tomas and Gerardo Llamera descended from their house and attacked the fallen victims with bolos, while Romualda L