Case Summary (G.R. No. 166408)
Applicable Law
The relevant constitutional framework for this case is based on the provisions set forth in the 1987 Philippine Constitution, as the decision date falls in 1988. The enforceability of the agreements and obligations concerning attorney’s fees is guided by the labor laws and principles of contract law applicable in the Philippines.
Background and Proceedings
The dispute originated on January 11, 1966, when NPCEWA initiated a strike against NPC, accusing it of failing to honor their collective bargaining agreement. This conflict was bifurcated into multiple related cases, ultimately leading to a resolution in the form of a Supplemental Agreement on July 9, 1973, which led to the withdrawal of all pending labor cases between the parties.
Validity of the Agreement and Attorney's Fees Issue
On March 1, 1979, the Supreme Court validated this Supplemental Agreement and authorized the withdrawal of previous labor cases. However, Attorney Simplicio J. Balcos, the former counsel for NPCEWA, contested the validity of the agreement, arguing that his claim for attorney's fees should not be barred by this resolution. The court directed the Secretary of Labor to determine the reasonable fees owed to Atty. Balcos, signaling that inquiries about the fees would continue.
Motion for Remittance and Dismissal of Claims
On September 5, 1979, Atty. Manansala, who had taken over as counsel for NPCEWA, filed a motion for the remittance of attorney’s fees. NPC moved to dismiss the motion, asserting it had already paid Atty. Manansala P10,000 and argued it held no further funds in trust. However, the Labor Arbiter denied this dismissal, maintaining that NPC, in its role as trustee, had an obligation to deliver remaining fees to Atty. Manansala.
Arbitration Orders and Execution Proceedings
Subsequent proceedings to execute the order for the partial remittance were impeded when a writ issued on December 3, 1979, was unsatisfied due to a refusal by the Commission on Audit to process a check NPC issued. This led to the levying of NPC’s deposits in February 1980 to satisfy the claims.
Calculations of Attorney's Fees
A detailed calculation revealed NPCEWA obtained various benefits totaling P12,774,000 as a result of the negotiations led by Atty. Manansala. During hearings, despite NPC’s absences, analysts reported the trust funds held by NPC amounted to P33,450.18. On May 14, 1980, the Labor Arbiter ordered NPC to remit P1,267,400 as attorney's fees, minus the previously paid P10,000.
Appeals Process and Final Decisions
NPC appealed against multiple NLRC ord
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 166408)
Case Background
- The case involves an appeal from the Resolution of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) dated 10 August 1983, concerning NLRC Case No. 65-IPA-CIR, where the National Power Corporation (NPC) was directed to deliver the amount of P33,450.18, held in trust for the National Power Corporation Employees and Workers Association (NPCEWA), to Attorney Gabriel V. Manansala.
- The dispute traces back to a strike staged by NPCEWA against NPC on 11 January 1966 due to alleged violations of their collective bargaining agreement, resulting in several related cases.
Procedural History
- On 9 July 1973, NPC and NPCEWA reached a Supplemental Agreement, resolving their differences and filing a joint Motion to Withdraw all pending labor cases against each other.
- Attorney Simplicio J. Balcos, the former counsel for NPCEWA, opposed this withdrawal, claiming it would deprive him of his attorney's fees.
- The Supreme Court affirmed the validity of the Supplemental Agreement and allowed the withdrawal of the labor cases on 1 March 1979.
Attorney’s Fees Claims
- After the withdrawal, on 5 September 1979, Atty. Gabriel V. Manansala filed a Motion for Remittance of Attorney's Fees, claiming compensation for his services rendered during the negotiations.
- NPC contested this motion, asserting a lack of jurisdiction and claiming they had already issued a check for P10,000.00 in favor of Atty. Manansala.
Labor Arbiter’s Order
- The Labor A