Case Summary (G.R. No. 157784)
Procedural History
The case originates from an action for reconveyance filed by Richard Lopez after the Regional Trial Court (RTC) in Balayan, Batangas dismissed his action on the basis of prescription. The RTC's summary judgment was affirmed by the Court of Appeals, prompting the current petition for review on certiorari.
Testamentary Intent and Establishment of Trust
Juliana Lopez-Manzano executed a notarial will on March 23, 1968, expressing her intent to create a trust (Fideicomiso) for her paraphernal properties, designated to be administered by her husband, Jose Lopez Manzano. In the event of his death or renunciation, her nephew, Enrique Lopez, was to become the administrator. Juliana passed away shortly after executing her will, and her husband secured its probate, leading to the acknowledgment of the Fideicomiso.
Probate and Adjudication of Properties
Upon Jose’s admission as the executor and trustee, a project of partition was filed, delineating the properties to be included in the Fideicomiso versus those to be adjudicated to Jose as an heir. Notably, the disputed properties were stated to be excluded from the Fideicomiso and were adjudicated entirely to Jose, with the probate court confirming the exclusion.
Death of Jose and Subsequent Actions
Jose Lopez Manzano died on July 22, 1980, leaving a holographic will that bequeathed the disputed properties to the respondents, leading to the issuance of new certificate titles in their names. The petitioner's father took over the trusteeship of Juliana's estate, and in December 1984, Richard Lopez filed for reconveyance against the respondents, arguing that the properties were originally Juliana's paraphernal properties and should not have been included in Jose's estate.
Dismissal Based on Prescription
The RTC ruled that petitioner’s claim had prescribed, computing the prescription period from the date the properties were registered in the name of Jose on September 15, 1969. The Court of Appeals confirmed this ruling, maintaining that the action for reconveyance was barred by the lapse of time.
Legal Analysis of Trust Status
A central element of the case revolves around whether Jose's role as trustee constituted an implied or express trust. Petitioner contended that an express trust was established over the disputed properties, while the courts characterized the situation as one involving an implied trust. The ruling emphasized that while an express trust is based on direct intent, an implied trust can arise from the nature of the parties' actions or legal consequences, especially involving erroneous registrations.
Grounds for Constructive Trust
The courts noted that the properties were explicitly excluded from the Fideicomiso, leading to an adjudication of properties to Jose as his inheritance, which might have been mistakenly assessed. The nature of the exclusion and the corresponding court approval conferred a presumption of regularity to the adjudication, thus operating as a constructive trust rather than an express one.
Prescription an
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 157784)
Case Background
- The case involves a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure.
- Petitioner Richard B. Lopez seeks to overturn the decision and resolution of the Court of Appeals which affirmed a summary judgment by the Regional Trial Court (RTC) dismissing his action for reconveyance, citing prescription.
Parties Involved
- Petitioner: Richard B. Lopez, acting as trustee for the estate of the late Juliana Lopez-Manzano.
- Respondents: Corazon Lopez, Fernando Lopez, Roberto Lopez (represented by Luzviminda Lopez), and other heirs of Jose Lopez Manzano.
Facts of the Case
- Juliana Lopez-Manzano, deceased, owned various properties including over 1,500 hectares of land in Batangas and additional properties in Mindoro and Manila.
- On March 23, 1968, Juliana executed a notarial will establishing a trust fund (Fideicomiso) for her paraphernal properties to be administered by her husband, Jose Lopez Manzano.
- Jose was to inherit half of her paraphernal properties and manage the Fideicomiso, with the intention that two-thirds of the income would fund the education of deserving students.
- Following Juliana's death on August 12, 1968, Jose initiated the probate of her will, which was admitted to probate on October 7, 1968.
- In the probate proceedings, Jose submitted an inventory of Juliana's properties and a project of partition, wherein he claimed the disputed properties as his own inheritance.
The Disputed Properties
- The properties in question consist of six parcels of land located in Balayan, Bata