Case Summary (G.R. No. 247645)
Applicable Law
The case hinges on the constitutional powers granted to the Commission on Elections as outlined in the 1987 Philippine Constitution, particularly regarding its authority to enforce election laws and regulations, as well as the mechanisms for accrediting political parties under Republic Act No. 7166, as amended.
Summary of Proceedings
The Liberal Party sought accreditation as the Dominant Minority Party for the national and local elections scheduled for May 13, 2019. The Commission on Elections issued Resolution No. 10514 detailing the criteria for accreditation, which included considering the political party's historical performance in elections, the number of incumbent officials, and the ability to present a full slate of candidates, among other criteria. The Nacionalista Party was ultimately designated as the Dominant Minority Party in Resolution No. 10538.
Petitioner’s Claims
The Liberal Party contended that the COMELEC displayed grave abuse of discretion by not adhering to the Omnibus Election Code’s definition of a dominant opposition party when determining who qualified as the Dominant Minority Party. It claimed that the Nacionalista Party, being part of the ruling coalition, should not have been classified as "opposing" to the majority. The Liberal Party also sought the annulment of the COMELEC resolution and the establishment of clearer guidelines for future elections.
Respondents’ Arguments
The COMELEC and the Nacionalista Party maintained that the petition was moot since the elections had concluded, thus any relief sought regarding the accreditation would no longer hold practical significance. They asserted that the criteria used for designating the dominant parties were consistent with existing laws and did not constitute any abuse of discretion.
Judicial Findings
The court determined that the matter was moot due to the conclusion of the 2019 elections, which rendered the Petition for Certiorari without merit. The Court emphasized the requirement of an actual case or controversy for its jurisdiction to be engaged. Petitioner’s assertions were found not to contest the specific findings of Resolution No. 10538 but rather the methodology used in determining party accreditation. It was noteworthy that the Liberal Party did not contest the specific criteria established in Resolution No. 10
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 247645)
Case Overview
- Court: Supreme Court of the Philippines, En Banc
- Case Number: G.R. No. 247645
- Date of Decision: July 26, 2022
- Petitioner: Liberal Party, represented by its President Francis N. Pangilinan and/or its Secretary General Jose Christopher Y. Belmonte
- Respondents: Commission on Elections and Nacionalista Party, represented by its President Manuel B. Villar and/or its Secretary General Alan Peter Cayetano
Background of the Case
- The Commission on Elections (COMELEC) possesses constitutional authority to administer and enforce election-related laws, including the issuance of rules for political party accreditation.
- The case arose from a petition for certiorari filed by the Liberal Party challenging COMELEC's Resolution No. 10538, which denied its request for accreditation as the dominant minority party for the May 13, 2019 national and local elections.
- The COMELEC issued Resolution No. 10514 on March 25, 2019, outlining the criteria for determining political party accreditation, including provisions for official watchers and the designation of dominant majority and minority parties.
Key Provisions of Resolution No. 10514
- Criteria for Accreditation:
- Established record of political parties based on past election performance.
- Number of incumbent elective officials affiliated with the parties 90 days before the election.
- Organizational strength evidenced by organized chapters.
- Capability to fill a complete slate of candidates up to the presidential level.
- Inclusion of the number of women candidates fielded by political parties.
Events Leading to the Petition
- The Liberal Party submitted its Petition for Accreditation on April 10, 2019.
- On May 8, 2019, COMELEC issued Resolution No. 10538, w