Case Summary (A.M. No. RTJ-07-2060)
Background of the Cases
Civil Case No. 1184 involved a P6,500.00 loan, while Civil Case No. 1187 involved a P7,250.00 loan. Judgments were rendered against the Jalbuenas, including awards for litigation and attorney's fees. Writs of execution were subsequently issued to satisfy the judgments, leading to the seizure and auctioning of a motorized tricycle, allegedly owned by the complainant, and its sidecar.
Auction Proceedings and Claims
Respondents executed a notice of sale, which was followed by an auction on August 31, 1992. The motorcycle was sold for P35,000.00 to Ilawod, with Norkis Distributors, Inc. receiving P34,975.00 as the unpaid balance for the motorcycle, while Ilawod retained a minor surplus of P25.00. The sidecar was sold to Ilawod for P10,000.00. Jalbuena raised concerns regarding the auction process, including improper demands for settlement, lack of notification of the auction sale, and the handling of excess proceeds.
Legal Framework
The applicable legal provisions are found in Section 15 and Section 17 of Rule 39 of the Rules of Court, which define the procedure for enforcing money judgments, including the handling of properties levied upon, third-party claims, and the distribution of proceeds from the sale.
Respondents' Defense
In response to the accusations, the respondents argued compliance with the procedural requirements of the auction process. They contended that the Jalbuenas were aware of the auction, as notices were posted in conspicuous locations, and that they refused to acknowledge receipt of served notices.
Judicial Findings on Procedure
The judicial review revealed significant procedural discrepancies. Despite the respondents’ assertions, it was determined that the execution sales did not properly account for the excess proceeds from the sold properties, which should have been returned to the judgment debtor, Jalbuena, rather than being disbursed to third-party claimants.
...continue readingCase Syllabus (A.M. No. RTJ-07-2060)
Case Overview
- Complainant Roberto Jalbuena accuses respondents Edgardo Gellada (Clerk of Court IV and Ex-Officio Sheriff) and Rex Fuentebella (Sheriff III) of the Municipal Trial Court, Bago City, Negros Occidental.
- The allegations include dishonesty, grave misconduct, and corrupt practices related to the execution of money judgments in Civil Case Nos. 1184 and 1187.
Background of the Cases
- Roberto Jalbuena is the defendant in Civil Case No. 1184, initiated by Ilawod Farmer’s Multi-Purpose Cooperative, Inc., for the collection of a P6,500 crop loan.
- Jalbuena's wife, Magdalena Jalbuena, is named as a defendant in Civil Case No. 1187, concerning a claim for P7,250 from the same cooperative.
- Judgments were rendered against both Jalbuenas, with specific amounts for litigation fees and costs of suit included in the judgments.
Issuance and Service of Writs of Execution
- The trial court issued writs of execution upon the motion of the judgment creditor Ilawod.
- The writ against Magdalena Jalbuena was issued on October 8, 1991, and allegedly served on October 16, 1991.
- The writ against Roberto Jalbuena was issued on October 16, 1991, and allegedly served on October 17, 1991.
- The writ was read to Magdalena Jalbuena by her daughter, as she was not proficient in English.
Levy and Third Party Claims
- On October 16, 1991, a motorized tricycle parked at the Jalbuenas' residence was levied upon.
- Norkis Distributors, Inc. claimed ownership of the motorcycle, asserting it was sold to Jalbuena on an installment basis with an unpaid balance of P34,975, secured by a chattel mortgage.
- Hernando Nacion filed a third-party claim for the tricycle's sidecar related to Civil Case No. 1187