Case Summary (G.R. No. L-20895)
Applicable Law and Naturalization Requirements
The core issue revolves around the petitioner’s application for naturalization under Philippine law, specifically the requirements set forth in the Naturalization Law, which necessitates that any applicant must possess a lucrative occupation or calling. The requirement aims to ensure that an applicant has a stable financial standing that allows them to support themselves and contribute to the community as a citizen.
Background of the Petition
The petitioner filed his naturalization petition on October 13, 1959, claiming an annual income of P1,800.00 from his job as a salesman at the Globe Bicycle Store in Manila. Two witnesses, former Congressman Conrado Morente and Mayor Dominador Madrid, testified to his good moral character, which is also a prerequisite for naturalization.
Grounds for Appeal
The Solicitor General appealed the court’s decision to grant the petition, asserting that the lower court erred based on several grounds: (1) Yu’s failure to disclose all former places of residence; (2) the inadequacy of his claimed annual income; and (3) the use of an alias without judicial authority. The appeal primarily focused on the insufficiency of the petitioner’s reported income as satisfying the necessary criteria for naturalization.
Court's Analysis of Income Sufficiency
The court noted that the applicant's declared income of P1,800.00, equivalent to P150.00 per month, is insufficient to meet the legal standard. Previous case law highlighted that this amount is below the threshold requirements established by similar rulings, which have consistently held that a minimum income of P200.00 per month is inadequate. Furthermore, even an additional income from tutorials that boosted his total monthly income to P250.00 was also deemed insufficient. The decisions referenced included several related cases where the courts invalidated petitions based on inadequate income levels.
Fi
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. L-20895)
Case Overview
- The case revolves around the petition for naturalization of Ramon Hong Chiong Yu, also known as Ramon L. Young.
- The appeal is made by the Solicitor General against the decision of the Court of First Instance of Oriental Mindoro, which granted the petition for naturalization.
- The ruling was delivered on February 28, 1969, under G.R. No. L-20895.
Background of the Petitioner
- Ramon Hong Chiong Yu was born on January 15, 1934, to Chinese parents in Capiz (now Roxas City), Province of Capiz.
- He has resided continuously in the Philippines since birth.
- His educational background includes completing elementary education at Aklan College, a Catholic institution, and high school at Northwestern Visayan College, both located in Kalibo, Aklan.
- At the time of the hearing, he was residing in Pinamalayan, Oriental Mindoro, and was a fourth-year chemical engineering student at the Mapua Institute of Technology in Manila.
Financial Standing
- The petition filed on October 13, 1959, stated that his annual income was P1,800.00, which translates to P150.00 monthly.
- He worked as a salesman at the Globe Bicycle Store located at 564 Plaza C. de la Barca, Manila.
- Add