Case Summary (G.R. No. 126703)
Factual Background and Origin of Dispute
Silvestre Germano, an employee of Gandara Mill Supply with only two employees including himself, was absent from work from February 6 to 11, 1995, without notifying his employer. His absence was to be near his wife, who was expected to deliver a child on February 12, 1995. After his return, Milagros Sy informed him that an employee had been hired to replace him and advised that he might be re-admitted in mid-1996. Germano filed a complaint for illegal dismissal on February 27, 1995. Negotiations to settle for P5,000 were offered by the petitioner but rejected by the respondent.
Procedural History and Labor Arbiter’s Decision
Following futile conciliation attempts, the Labor Arbiter required submission of position papers by the parties, allowing extensions until May 5, 1995, and a final deadline of seven days after the May 9, 1995 order. Despite these opportunities, petitioner did not submit its position paper, prompting the Labor Arbiter to rule in favor of Germano by decision dated January 29, 1996, awarding him P65,685.90 consisting of separation pay, back wages, service incentive leave pay, and attorney’s fees.
NLRC Decision on Appeal and Subsequent Proceedings
Petitioner appealed to the NLRC on March 4, 1996, but the appeal was dismissed on May 22, 1996, for failure to post a cash or surety bond. The petitioner sought exemption due to its status as a small business and requested additional days to comply, both of which were denied. The petitioner’s motion for reconsideration was likewise denied on July 23, 1996. Execution orders for the award were subsequently issued and enforced in favor of Germano.
Issues for Resolution
- Whether the NLRC committed grave abuse of discretion in dismissing petitioner’s appeal and denying the opportunity to prove that Germano was only suspended, not illegally dismissed.
- Whether the amount awarded to Germano was excessive.
Ruling on Due Process and Opportunity to be Heard
The Court found that the petitioner was afforded ample opportunities to be heard and to submit their position paper but failed to comply despite extensions granted. The petitioner’s claim of denial of due process was negated by these procedural leniencies. The Court emphasized that the orderly administration of justice requires strict observance of reglementary periods to prevent undue delay. The concept of laches was invoked to emphasize petitioner’s unreasonable delay and neglect in prosecuting their defenses.
Representation and Procedural Diligence
Petitioner’s lack of legal representation was a product of their own negligence. The non-lawyer representing them failed to effectively manage the case, leading to the unfavorable decision. While the right to counsel is fundamental, the Court noted that this right does not permit parties to undermine procedural rules or cause delays.
Legality of Dismissal and Observance of Due Process
Although Germano was absent without leave, the dismissal was illegal due to failure to observe the twin requisites of the WenPhil Doctrine: notice and hearing. The suspension imposed extended beyond the thirty-day maximum allowed under Labor Code rules, effectively rendering it an illegal dismissal. The petitioner’s offer to re-admit Germano was not formal and did not amount to reinstatement.
Application of Compassionate Justice Principle
The Court acknowledged the constitutional mandate for social justice and protection of labor, highlighting the need for moderation in sanctions against employees who are breadwinners with legitimate reasons for absence. The protracted suspension without pay violated labor protections, justifying the finding of illegal dismissal.
T
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 126703)
Case Background and Procedural History
- The case arises from a special civil action for Certiorari filed under Rule 65 of the Revised Rules of Court, challenging the resolutions of the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) dated May 22, 1996, and July 23, 1996.
- Petitioners Gandara Mill Supply and Milagros Sy contested the NLRC’s denial of their motion for reconsideration in NLRC NCR Case No. 00-02-1653-94.
- The private respondent, Silvestre Germano, instituted a case for illegal dismissal against Milagros Sy, owner of Gandara Mill Supply, following his absence from work from February 6 to 11, 1995.
- Germano’s absence was due to his wife's impending childbirth; she delivered on February 12, 1995.
- Despite no notification of absence, Milagros Sy extended some financial help to Germano’s family.
- The business was a small enterprise with only two employees, making any absence critical to operations.
- Germano returned to work after two weeks but was informed that someone else had been hired to replace him; he was told re-admission would occur only in June 1996.
- Germano filed for illegal dismissal on February 27, 1995, through the Department of Labor and Employment.
- Petitioners offered a P5,000.00 settlement offer, which Germano rejected outright.
Labor Arbiter Proceedings and Decision
- Conciliation efforts failed; the Labor Arbiter mandated submission of position papers by both parties—initially due April 28, 1995, extended to May 5, 1995.
- On May 9, 1995, the Labor Arbiter issued a final order requiring petitioners to file their position paper within seven days or waive their right to be heard.
- Petitioners failed to file the position paper despite receipt of the order.
- The Labor Arbiter consequently rendered a decision on January 29, 1996, ordering petitioners to pay Germano P65,685.90, representing separation pay, back wages, service incentive leave pay, and attorney’s fees.
NLRC Appeal and Rulings
- Petitioners appealed the Labor Arbiter’s decision on March 4, 1996, but failed to post the required cash or surety bond.
- On May 22, 1996, the NLRC dismissed the appeal for failure to post bond despite petitioners' claim that their small business status qualified them for exemption and their request for additional time to post the bond.
- A motion for reconsideration was denied as reflected in the NLRC’s Ju