Case Summary (G.R. No. 164225)
Relevant Facts
During the May 10, 2004 elections, serious disagreements among local candidates regarding the clustering of precincts, distribution of election materials, and appointment of election inspectors resulted in a failure of elections in Lumba-Bayabao. Following this, a special election was conducted on May 12, 2004, to resolve the electoral disputes. Petitioner Galo later filed a petition with COMELEC on May 19, claiming serious irregularities in the special election, including allegations of fake ballots being used and intimidation by Dagalangit’s supporters.
Petitioner’s Allegations
Galo's claims specified various alleged irregularities, including the insertion of fake ballots into ballot boxes and the refusal of election inspectors to acknowledge lawful objections during vote counting. He sought a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) to prevent the canvassing of election returns from affected precincts and requested an annulment of the election results, calling for an investigation into these allegations.
COMELEC Actions
On May 21, 2004, COMELEC issued a TRO, pausing the Municipal Board of Canvassers' proceedings concerning the election results. Dagalangit denied the accusations, asserting that the elections were conducted properly across all precincts.
Subsequent Developments
During a hearing on May 27, 2004, Galo did not personally attend but instead filed a motion indicating that he had been proclaimed the winner on May 20, 2004, claiming that this development rendered his original petition moot. The COMELEC En Banc, on July 2, 2004, dismissed Galo's petition for lack of merit and annulled his prior proclamation, citing that proper procedures had not been followed during the alleged election.
Decision of COMELEC
The COMELEC determined that the alleged use of fake ballots was insufficient by itself to declare a failure of elections. It highlighted that Galo failed to establish that no voting took place in the questionable precincts or that the alleged irregularities had materially affected the election result. By confirming that all 39 precincts operated fully during the special election, the Commission concluded that the election process did not warrant the annulment sought by the petitioner.
Legal Analysis
Pursuant to Section 6 of the Omnibus Election Code, specific conditions must be present for a declaration of failure of elections, including not holding elections due to force majeure, fraud, or analogous causes, or affecting the election's outcome due to voting irregularities. The Cou
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 164225)
Case Overview
- This case involves a Petition for Certiorari filed by Juhary A. Galo against the Commission on Elections (COMELEC), the Municipal Board of Canvassers of Lumba-Bayabao, Lanao del Sur, and Minda Dagalangit.
- The petition challenges the COMELEC's Resolution dated July 2, 2004, in SPA No. 04-348, which dismissed Galo's petition for declaring a failure of election and annulment of results from the May 12, 2004 special election.
Background of the Case
- Galo and Dagalangit were candidates for mayor in the Municipality of Lumba-Bayabao during the May 10, 2004 national and local elections.
- A failure of election occurred on May 10, 2004, due to disagreements among local candidates regarding the clustering of precincts, distribution of election materials, and appointment of election inspectors.
- Consequently, a special election was scheduled and conducted on May 12, 2004.
Petitioner's Allegations
- On May 19, 2004, Galo filed a petition with the COMELEC alleging serious and massive irregularities during the special election.
- Specific allegations included:
- Presence of fake ballots in Precinct No. 1A (Barangay Maribu).
- Irregularities in Precinct No. 34A (Barangay Sunggod) where election inspectors hid a ballot box.
- Discovery of fake ballots in multiple precincts (22A, 29B, 31A, 34A, and 36A) during vote counting.