Case Summary (G.R. No. 210905)
Facts of the Case
The events unfolded during the local election canvassing on May 16, 2007, which was disrupted by violence, leading to the unauthorized removal of Statements of Votes by Precinct (SOVP) by members of the Municipal Board of Canvassers. The actions of Melicano Bernan and Julio Collantes resulted in the theft of SOVPs covering a significant portion of the voting precincts. Manganaan filed a request with the COMELEC to nullify the affected SOVPs citing irregularities. Subsequent actions by the SBOC and the proclamation of winning candidates were contested due to these procedural anomalies.
Proceedings Before the COMELEC
In response to Manganaan's petition, Commissioner Brawner issued a memorandum ordering the nullification of certain SOVPs and directed a re-canvassing to ensure the integrity of the elections. Despite this, the SBOC prematurely proclaimed the petitioners as winners before the returning SOVPs could be accounted for, leading to the filing of a Petition to Annul Proclamation by Manganaan. The COMELEC ultimately resolved that the petition should be treated as one for correcting manifest errors in the SOVPs instead of solely a nullification action.
Legal Issues Presented
The central legal issues in the case encompassed whether the COMELEC exercised grave abuse of discretion in its treatment of Manganaan's petition, whether it correctly treated the petition as one to correct manifest errors, whether such a correction could occur post-proclamation, and whether the petitioners' right to due process had been violated.
Developments During Pendency of the Petition
Amid the pendency of the petition, the SBOC reconvened, annulled the initial proclamation, and subsequently proclaimed Manganaan as the duly elected mayor. In turn, Flauta pursued an election protest before the Regional Trial Court. This development raised the question of whether the COMELEC's actions had rendered Manganaan's initial petition moot.
Arguments and Rulings
Petitioners contended that the non-inclusion of Manganaan's petition in the COMELEC's Resolution No. 8212 indicated a dismissal of the case and argued against the propriety of the COMELEC converting the annulment petition to a correction of manifest errors, asserting that such a conversion violated procedural rules post-proclamation. Conversely, Manganaan maintained that his subsequent proclamation rendered the petition moot and emphasized the procedural necessity for correcting manifest errors to uphold the integrity of the election results.
COMELEC’s Powers and Functions
The COMELEC affirmed its authoritative role in supervising and controlling election processes, including the adjustment of proclamations based on election law violations. The Court asserted that the determi
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 210905)
Case Overview
- This case involves a petition for certiorari and prohibition filed by Rafael Flauta, Jr., Lucresia Ordinario, Nemesio Gose, Ricardo Bajade, Joseph Orayle, Gil Batilo, Romulo Hilario, Bevelyn Zapanta, and Genoviva Jehodo against the Commission on Elections (COMELEC).
- The petition seeks to nullify the Resolution dated September 25, 2008, wherein the COMELEC denied the petition of Dante Manganaan to annul certain Statements of Votes by Precinct (SOVP) and treated his petition as one to correct manifest errors.
- The context revolves around the May 15, 2007 local elections in the Municipality of Senator Ninoy Aquino, Sultan Kudarat.
Background Facts
- Rafael Flauta, Jr. was proclaimed mayor following the May 15, 2007 elections, while the other petitioners were proclaimed as vice mayor and council members.
- A disruption occurred during the canvassing on May 16, 2007, due to explosions and gunfire, leading to the absence of SOVPs from the canvassing venue.
- Melicano Bernan and Julio Collantes, officials of the Municipal Board of Canvassers, removed SOVPs with serial numbers 0000877, 0000878, 0000879, and partially filled SOVP No. 0000880, which were crucial for the canvassing process.
- A police certification confirmed the incident, indicating the gravity of the disruption to the election process.
Initial Actions and Resolutions
- On May 23, 2007, Manganaan requested the nullification of the SOVPs due to the aforementioned incident.
- The COMELEC, th