Case Summary (G.R. No. L-47350)
Background Facts
The original lease dates back to 1899, established between the original owners and the father of the private respondent, Rufino Fernandez. Following the father's death, Fernandez continued the lease. The property was sold to the petitioner by the original owners on July 9, 1974, for P250,000. After the sale, a temporary arrangement was made wherein Fernandez continued to pay rent—initially paying P625.00 for the first half of July 1974 to the former owners and subsequently to the petitioner. A verbal agreement was reached to increase the monthly rent to P2,000.00 starting in August 1974.
Dispute and Initial Court Rulings
In October 1975, petitioner notified Fernandez that the lease would end on October 31, 1975, but Fernandez refused to vacate the premises. As a result, the petitioner filed a complaint for unlawful detainer before the City Court of Iloilo. The City Court ruled in favor of Fernandez, dismissing the complaint and determining a monthly rental rate of P3,000, in addition to setting a lease duration of 7.5 years based on the previous years of occupancy.
Appeals and Modifications
The decision of the City Court was appealed to the Court of First Instance, which modified the judgment by reducing the lease duration to one year upon finality of the decision. Fernandez then sought a review from the Court of Appeals, which ultimately extended the lease by an additional five years while affirming other aspects of the prior rulings.
Legal Issues Raised by the Petitioner
The petitioner contested the Court of Appeals decision, arguing that it constituted a grave error in applying Article 1687 of the New Civil Code. The petitioner claimed:
- The Court effectively made a new contract between the parties, contradicting the intent of Article 1687.
- The lower court had not demonstrated grave abuse of discretion by limiting the lease term to one year.
- The conclusions drawn by the Court of Appeals were contrary to law and the established facts.
- The Court failed to apply the criteria set forth in previous jurisprudence.
Court’s Reasoning and Decision
The Supreme Court examined the application of Article 1687, noting that the court does possess the discretion to extend lease periods within equitable contexts. The court's analysis emphasized that the purpose of Article 1687 is to define the duration of a lease if it remains indefinite. The petitioner's assertion that the lease's reckoning should only begin with Fernandez’s occupancy was rejected, as the law presumes continuity of agreements despite ownership changes, unless stated otherwise in a contract.
The Court found that factors presented by the petitioner—ownership change, commercial premises distinction, and future intentions of u
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. L-47350)
Case Overview
- The case involves a petition for certiorari to review the decision of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. No. S.P. 06585, dated September 22, 1977.
- The petitioner is F. S. Divinagracia Agro-Commercial, Inc., while the respondents are the Honorable Court of Appeals and Rufino Fernandez.
- The Supreme Court's decision was promulgated on April 21, 1981, delivered by Justice Guerrero.
Background Facts
- The original lease of a building and lot, owned by the late Dona Concepcion Gay de Loring and the spouses Mercedes Van Kauffman and Jaime Ibanez de Aldecoa, dates back to 1899.
- After the original lessee (Fernandez's father) passed away, Rufino Fernandez continued the lease.
- The petitioner purchased the property from the intestate estate of the original owners for P250,000.00 on July 9, 1974.
- At the time of purchase, Rufino Fernandez was paying P1,250.00 per month in rent.
- A verbal agreement was reached to increase the rent to P2,000.00 per month starting August 1974, which continued until September 1975.
Lease Termination and Legal Proceedings
- In October 1975, Rufino Fernandez was informed that the lease would terminate on October 31, 1975.
- Upon Fernandez's refusal to vacate the premises, the petitioner filed an unlawful detainer complaint against him in the City Court of Iloilo.
- The City Court dismissed the complaint and ordered Fernandez to pay P3,000.00 monthly rent starting January 1976, extending the lease for seven and a half years.
Appeal and Court Decisions
- The petitioner appealed to the Court of First Instance, which modified the C