Case Summary (G.R. No. 159586)
Contractual Agreements and Assignments
On October 6, 1999, CDC and the German Consortium executed a Contract for Services which stipulated that the German Consortium would manage the waste management center and allowed it to impose a "tipping fee" for waste collected within the CSEZ. Significantly, Article VIII, Section 7 of the Contract mandated the formation of a local corporation by the Consortium as its representative. Subsequently, on April 18, 2000, the Consortium entered into a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with D.M. Wenceslao and Associates, Inc. and LBV and Associates, agreeing to form a local corporation to be identified and structured under specified equity shares among themselves.
Termination of Agreements
The relationship between the parties began to deteriorate following the failure to execute the Shareholders' Agreement within the stipulated timeframe of one month post-MOU. On August 1, 2000, the German Consortium ceded rights and obligations under the Contract for Services to ERTI via a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA). However, the disagreement culminated in a letter from the Consortium on December 11, 2000, indicating the termination of all agreements, primarily due to non-approval from the CDC regarding the assignment of rights to ERTI.
Legal Proceedings
In response to allegations of misrepresentation by ERTI towards third parties regarding their rights under the waste management contract, the German Consortium filed for an injunction in the Regional Trial Court. ERTI contended that the trial court lacked jurisdiction since the German Consortium was composed of foreign entities allegedly doing business in the Philippines without proper licensing. Anticipating the legal contention, ERTI demanded arbitration in accordance with the MOA’s provisions amidst the ongoing court proceedings.
Trial Court and Court of Appeals Rulings
On June 28, 2001, the trial court issued a preliminary injunction against ERTI, leading to their filing for a motion for reconsideration, which was denied. This denial prompted a petition for certiorari to the Court of Appeals, which ultimately upheld the trial court's ruling. ERTI's arguments included that the respondents lacked the capacity to sue, a concern dismissed by the appellate court.
Jurisdictional Issues and Foreign Corporations
The Supreme Court addressed whether the German Consortium, as unlicensed foreign corporations, had the standing to sue in the Philippines. Citing Section 133 of the Corporation Code, the Court emphasized that without a license to transact business in the Philippines, foreign corporations could not maintain actions in local courts. The participation of the German Consortium in the bidding process was deemed as conducting business, thereby necessitating a license that they did not possess.
Estoppel and Capacity to Sue
While the Court acknowledged some exceptions to the general rule regarding foreign corporations, it found no basis for estoppel in this case. Petitioners did not benefit from any transactions with the German Consortium and were not in breach of obligation
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 159586)
Case Overview
- The petition was filed under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court against the Decision of the Court of Appeals dated May 15, 2003.
- The Court of Appeals sustained the Order of the Regional Trial Court of Angeles City, Branch 61, dated June 28, 2001, which issued a writ of preliminary injunction against the petitioners.
- The parties involved include European Resources and Technologies, Inc. (ERTI) and Delfin J. Wenceslao as petitioners, and Ingenieuburo Birkhan + Nolte, Ingeniurgesellschaft MBH, and Heers & Brockstedt GmbH & Co. collectively referred to as the German Consortium as respondents.
Background of the Case
- The German Consortium submitted a bid to the Clark Development Corporation (CDC) for the construction, operation, and management of an Integrated Waste Management Center at the Clark Special Economic Zone (CSEZ).
- Following acceptance of their bid, a Contract for Services was executed on October 6, 1999, allowing the German Consortium to impose a tipping fee for waste collected from CSEZ locators and residents.
- A Joint Venture was formed on April 18, 2000, involving D.M. Wenceslao and Associates, Inc. (DMWAI) and Ma. Elena B. Villarama to establish a local corporation for the project.
Agreements and Termination
- The German Consortium ceded its rights and obligations under the Contract for Services to ERTI on August 1, 2000, via a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA).
- On December 11, 2000, the German Consortium declared the termination of the agreement, cit