Case Summary (G.R. No. 199810)
Relevant Circumstances
Iglesia ni Kristo applied for the registration and confirmation of ownership of the land parcel, initiating the application in the Court of First Instance, which was identified as LRC No. N-187-O. The petitioner opposed the application, arguing that as a private corporation, Iglesia ni Kristo was disqualified from acquiring land from the public domain per Article XIV, Section 11 of the 1987 Philippine Constitution, which limits such acquisitions.
Acquisition and Tax Declaration
The Iglesia ni Kristo acquired the property from Gregorio Rolls and Romualdo Rolls on May 23, 1946, and subsequently had it declared for taxation purposes. The title of the property has been recognized through tax declarations since 1974, and the land is exempt from real property taxes as it is primarily used for religious purposes.
Lower Court Ruling
On June 2, 1980, the trial court ruled in favor of Iglesia ni Kristo, confirming its title to the land. The court found that the church had maintained open, public, adverse, peaceful, and continuous possession of the land since its acquisition, having constructed a chapel on the property. The court's ruling noted that the land was not within any military or naval reservation.
Legal Precedent and Doctrine Application
The Supreme Court applied the doctrine established in Director of Lands v. Intermediate Appellate Court, wherein it was held that the previous case's conclusion—that prolonged possession of public land under particular conditions results in the land ceasing to be public and becoming private property—remains relevant and applicable to the current matter.
Significance of Prior Case Law
The court referenced the 1986 decision which emphasized that possession of public land for the requisite period creates a legal presumption of ownership, thereby elevating the matter of title confirmation to a mere formality. Decisions in cases like Herico v. Dar and others have established that rights vested prior to the prohibition in the current constitution should be recognized and upheld.
Final Court Decision
The Supreme Court ultimat
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 199810)
Case Overview
- This case involves an appeal by the Director of Lands against the decision of the Court of First Instance of Zambales and Olongapo, which granted the Iglesia ni Kristo a title to a parcel of land.
- The primary legal issue revolves around the ability of a private corporation to acquire land of the public domain, as governed by the 1973 Constitution.
Facts of the Case
- The Iglesia ni Kristo filed an application for the registration and confirmation of title over a 280 square meter parcel of land located at Barrio Consuelo Sur, Municipality of San Marcelino, Province of Zambales.
- The application was assigned to the Court of First Instance of Zambales & Olongapo, Branch III, presided over by Judge Domingo D. Panis.
- The Republic (Director of Lands) opposed the application on the basis that the Iglesia ni Kristo, as a private corporation, was disqualified from acquiring public land, according to Article XIV, Section 11 of the Constitution.
- The land in question had been acquired by the Iglesia ni Kristo from Gregorio and Romualdo Rolls on May 23, 1946, as evidenced by a Deed of Sale.
- The property was declared for taxation purpose