Case Summary (G.R. No. 132413)
Background and Case Evolution
Following the barangay elections held on May 12, 1997, Ramon Alquizola, Sr. was elected as Punong Barangay of Barangay Tubod, Iligan City. Upon his assumption of office, he dismissed the existing appointees of the previous punong barangay, specifically replacing key positions such as the barangay treasurer and barangay secretary with his co-petitioners, Doromal and Seco. Alquizola submitted these appointments to the Sangguniang Barangay for approval, but the Sanggunian rejected them. This led the dismissed respondents to initiate legal action in the Regional Trial Court, seeking a judicial order to reinstate them into their respective positions.
Judicial Findings
The Regional Trial Court ruled in favor of the respondents, concluding that Alquizola's dismissal of the respondents was unlawful due to the lack of necessary approval from the Sangguniang Barangay as stipulated by the Local Government Code. The court found that Section 389(b)(5) mandates that the Punong Barangay requires the majority approval of the Sanggunian to remove or appoint barangay officials, including the treasurer and secretary. The court's reasoning was anchored on the premise that without such approval, any dismissal or appointment lacks legal standing.
Legal Principles and Reasoning
The ruling emphasized the interpretation of "replace" within the context of Section 389, indicating that to effectuate a replacement, there must first be a removal or vacancy in the office. Alquizola, having acted unilaterally without the consent of the Sanggunian, could not justify the dismissals legally. The court noted that the Local Government Code implicitly incorporates the power to remove officials as an essential component of the power to appoint, thereby reinforcing the legislative intent to require collaborative gove
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. 132413)
Case Overview
- The case involves a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court.
- The petitioners are Ramon Alquizola, Sr., Marissa C. Doromal, and Adelo Seco; the respondents are Gallardo Ocol, Camilo P. Penaco, Saturnino Mendoza, Rafael R. Ardiente, Vicente C. Caseres, Ricardo B. Zosa III, and Sirad M. Umpa.
- The decision being contested is dated November 19, 1997, from the Regional Trial Court of Lanao Del Norte, Branch 04, Iligan City.
- The trial court ordered petitioner Ramon Alquizola, Sr. to cease and desist from dismissing the respondents and replacing them with his co-petitioners.
Background Facts
- Ramon Alquizola, Sr. was elected as the Punong Barangay of Barangay Tubod, Iligan City, during the barangay elections held on May 12, 1997.
- The respondents were appointed by the former Punong Barangay, with Gallardo Ocol serving as barangay treasurer and Camilo Penaco as barangay secretary, while the others were barangay utility workers.
- After his election, Alquizola terminated the services of the respondents and appointed Doromal and Seco as the new barangay treasurer and barangay secretary, respectively.
- These appointments were submitted to the Sangguniang Barangay for approval but were rejected.
Legal Proceedings
- Following the rejection of the appointments, the respondents filed a complaint f