Case Summary (G.R. No. L-12168)
Background of the Case
Emilio B. Aller was appointed to the role of clerk in the office of the Provincial Auditor of Cebu on January 1, 1951, being eligible under the first-grade civil service examination. On August 31, 1952, his position was abolished by the Provincial Board, which Aller contended was carried out in bad faith and motivated by political reasons. Subsequently, on September 27, 1955, he filed a complaint seeking the recreation of his position and his reinstatement therein.
Respondent's Defense
In their response, former Governor Osmena and the Provincial Auditor denied any wrongdoing associated with the abolition of Aller’s position, asserting that it was part of a policy of retrenchment. They also claimed that such action was approved by the Secretary of Finance and argued that Aller had no cause of action, having failed to appeal the decision to the Auditor-General and to the President of the Philippines before approaching the court.
Procedural History
During the pending trial, the respondents moved to dismiss the case, positing that Aller’s complaint had not been filed within the one-year period necessary for such actions. The Court of First Instance of Cebu granted the motion to dismiss, leading Aller to appeal the dismissal.
Court's Decision on Procedural Grounds
In the appellate court, a motion to dismiss was filed on the additional premise that the Province of Cebu had not been made a party defendant in the case. The court agreed with this argument, referencing the precedent set in Cabanes vs. Rodriguez, which underscored the necessity of including the province in such legal actions.
Lack of Cause of Action and Final Judgment
Moreover, the court held that Aller’s petition failed to state a cause of action, as his position's abolition had been sanctioned by the Secretary of Finance. Consequently, the appe
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. L-12168)
Case Information
- Citation: 105 Phil. 243
- G.R. No.: L-12168
- Date of Decision: February 28, 1959
- Petitioner/Appellant: Emilio B. Aller
- Respondents/Appellees: Sergio Osmeña, Jr. (Former Provincial Governor), Pedro Uy Calderon (Acting Provincial Governor), The Provincial Board of Cebu, Ladislao Palma (Former Provincial Treasurer), F. Ordonez (Present Provincial Auditor), Rosario D. Macrohon (Present Provincial Treasurer)
Procedural Background
- Petitioner Emilio B. Aller filed a complaint seeking the recreation of his position and reinstatement after it was allegedly abolished by the Provincial Board of Cebu.
- The complaint was filed on September 27, 1955, nearly three years after the abolition of his position, which occurred on August 31, 1952.
- The Court of First Instance of Cebu dismissed the action, citing the untimeliness of the complaint and failure to name the Province of Cebu as a party defendant.
Factual Background
- Appointment: Aller was appointed clerk in the office of th