Case Summary (G.R. No. L-35095)
Employment Details and Medical Condition
Abundio Alburan was employed as a driver by the Department of Health since February 15, 1955, with a daily wage of P14.66. During his employment, he developed serious health issues, including glomerulonephritis and rheumatoid arthritis, which his physician, Dr. Modesto Villarin, attributed to the nature of his work as a driver, exposing him to various physical and environmental strains. The petitioner experienced several sick leave periods due to his health conditions, with significant time off between 1973 and 1974.
Claims and Legal Proceedings
In June 1974, Alburan filed a notice of sickness and claim for compensation benefits with the Workmen's Compensation Unit, which acknowledged his employment and the nature of his illness. Despite his submission of evidence to support his claim, including medical reports and statements about his work conditions, the claim was dismissed by the Acting Referee in January 1975, citing insufficient supporting documents. Alburan subsequently filed an ex-parte motion to have the case heard, allowing both parties the opportunity to present evidence.
Failure to Provide Due Process
The Workmen’s Compensation Commission affirmed the dismissal of Alburan's claim on January 26, 1976. The petitioner argued that he was denied due process, as he had not been afforded a proper hearing to present evidence supporting his claim for disability benefits. Notably, he sought redress by filing a motion for reconsideration when he became aware that records pertaining to his case were misplaced, indicating a lack of administrative diligence on the part of the Department of Health.
Legal Arguments and Contentions
The Solicitor General, representing the respondent, rebutted claims of due process violations by stating that existing guidelines allowed the dismissal of cases where sufficient evidence was lacking. However, Alburan's counsel contended that procedural norms outlined in Labor Department Orders required a hearing to determine the compensability of the illness, which were not adhered to in Alburan's case.
Court's Analysis and Findings
The Court found merit in Alburan's petition, emphasizing the grave abuse of discretion by the Workmen's Compensation Commission. It acknowledged Alburan's persistent efforts to pursue his claim, including the submission of necessary documents and seeking hearings. The Court also recog
...continue readingCase Syllabus (G.R. No. L-35095)
Case Overview
- This case involves a petition for review filed by Abundio Alburan against the Republic of the Philippines (Department of Health).
- The petition seeks to overturn the decision rendered on January 26, 1976, by the Workmen's Compensation Commission, which upheld the dismissal of Alburan's claim for sickness benefits by the Acting Referee of Regional Office No. 4.
Facts of the Case
- Abundio Alburan was employed as a driver by the Department of Health since February 15, 1955, stationed at Malaria Unit No. C-17 in Catbalogan, Samar, earning a daily wage of P14.66.
- On May 19, 1973, he underwent a medical examination and was diagnosed with "Glomerulonephritis Hypertension (Essential) Rheumatoid Arthritis," conditions attributed to the demands of his job.
- Alburan had a history of sick leaves due to his ailments, totaling 249 days over several years.
- In June 1974, he filed a notice of sickness and a claim for compensation benefits, documented as R04-WC Case No. 154362.
Procedural History
- Following the filing of his claim, a motion to set the case for hearing was filed on July 10, 1974.
- The Office of the Solicitor General submitted a controversion to the claim on July 24, 1974.
- In early 1975, Alburan submitted various documents in support of his claim, but by January 15, 1975, the