Case Digest (G.R. No. 42660)
Facts:
- In June 1932, Crispin Iman began courting 17-year-old Corazon Arcadio.
- Initially unsuccessful, Corazon reciprocated his affections by August 1932 after Crispin's persistent efforts and promises of marriage.
- In April 1933, Corazon wanted to end the relationship due to Crispin's indecent proposals, but they reconciled each time he professed his love.
- In May 1933, while Corazon's parents were away, Crispin engaged in sexual relations with her after renewing his marriage promise.
- Their relationship became sexual, and by October 1933, Corazon discovered she was pregnant.
- Crispin initially agreed to marry her but later claimed he was engaged to another woman.
- Corazon's parents intervened, leading to police involvement.
- On November 7, 1933, Crispin promised to marry Corazon in front of the chief of police but later refused due to family disapproval and religious differences.
- Corazon gave birth to a son on March 9, 1934.
- The prosecution presented letters from Crispin affirming their romantic relationship and his marriage promise.
- The trial court found Crispin guilty of seduction under Article 338 of the Revised Penal Code.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court affirmed the trial court's decision, finding Crispin Iman guilty of seduction.
- The court determined that the essential elements of the crime were present, including the promise of marriage and s...(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The court emphasized that the promise of marriage is crucial in establishing deceit in seduction cases.
- A prior promise influencing the victim's consent suffices; it does not need to be reiterated immediately before the act.
- Corazon's chastity was compromised due to Crispin's repeated promises, leading her to yield to his advances.
- The absence of...continue reading
Case Digest (G.R. No. 42660)
Facts:
In June 1932, Crispin Iman began courting Corazon Arcadio, a 17-year-old girl. Initially, his advances were unsuccessful, but by August of the same year, after persistent efforts and promises of marriage, Corazon reciprocated his affections. Their relationship faced challenges, particularly in April 1933, when Corazon expressed her desire to end their relationship due to Crispin's repeated indecent proposals. However, each time she threatened to break up, Crispin would profess his love, and they would reconcile. In May 1933, while Corazon's parents were away, Crispin took advantage of the situation and, after renewing his promise to marry her, engaged in sexual relations with her. Following this encounter, their relationship became sexual rather than platonic.
By October 1933, Corazon discovered she was pregnant and sought Crispin's commitment to marry her. Initially, he agreed, but later he claimed he was engaged to another woman. The couple lived together for a period, but Corazon's parents intervened, leading to a report to the police. On November 7, 1933, Crispin again promised to marry Corazon in front of the chief of police, but ultimately he refused, citing disapproval from his family and religious differences. Corazon gave birth to a son on March 9, 1934. The prosecution presented letters from Crispin to Corazon, affirming thei...