M.Y. Intercontinental Trading Corporation, Tedwin T. Uy, and Allianz Marketing and Publishing Corporation vs. St. Mary's Publishing Corporation and Jerry Vicente S. Catabijan

G.R. No. 249715
St. Mary’s Publishing sued M.Y. Intercontinental for copyright infringement after a forged Deed of Assignment led to unauthorized book sales. Courts upheld forgery claims, affirmed infringement, awarded damages, and remanded counterclaims for unpaid obligations.

Case Digest (G.R. No. 249715)

Facts:

M.Y. Intercontinental Trading Corporation, Tedwin T. Uy, and Allianz Marketing and Publishing Corporation v. St. Mary's Publishing Corporation and Jerry Vicente S. Catabijan, G.R. No. 249715, April 12, 2023, Second Division, Leonen, SAJ., writing for the Court. The petitioners are M.Y. Intercontinental Trading Corporation (M.Y. Intercontinental), its principal Tedwin T. Uy (Uy), and Allianz Marketing and Publishing Corporation (Allianz); the respondents are St. Mary’s Publishing Corporation (St. Mary’s Publishing) and its President/Publisher Jerry Vicente S. Catabijan (Catabijan).

St. Mary’s Publishing owned a series of textbooks (Developing Reading Power and Pagpapaunlad ng Kasanayan sa Pagbasa). Beginning in 2005 it entered a business relationship with M.Y. Intercontinental and Uy to fund and arrange printing of the books in China by Fujian New Technology Color Making and Printing Company, Ltd. The parties executed a financing agreement (Contract Ref. No. SMPCMY 76M 009) providing a principal loan for printing costs (Php 76,748,494.68), post-dated checks as security, and interest and penalty provisions. St. Mary’s issued purchase orders to M.Y. Intercontinental for specific print runs, including a December 7, 2009 purchase order for 301,000 copies.

St. Mary’s defaulted on payments; parties executed assorted settlement instruments (a Declaration of Pledge, a promissory note, and a March 12, 2010 Memorandum of Agreement establishing a joint account for collections). Sometime in April 2010 a Deed of Assignment purporting to transfer St. Mary’s copyrights to Uy/M.Y. Intercontinental was presented; petitioners later registered Copyright Registration Nos. A2012-24 to A2012-35 in M.Y. Intercontinental’s name on January 18, 2012. M.Y. Intercontinental filed a separate declaratory relief action in the RTC of Mandaluyong, which declared it an unpaid seller with a lien on the printed books and the right to resell them.

In 2012 St. Mary’s discovered that M.Y. Intercontinental had marketed and sold the books (including sales to the City of Cabuyao) and that Allianz had imported and sold copies. On March 13, 2013 St. Mary’s filed a complaint for copyright infringement in the RTC of Manila, Branch 24, against M.Y. Intercontinental, Uy, Fujian and Allianz, seeking injunctive relief and damages.

At trial St. Mary’s presented evidence and expert reports that Catabijan’s signature in the Deed of Assignment was forged; Catabijan denied executing the deed and filed criminal complaints. Uy testified he received a signed deed; petitioners relied on their registered copyrights. The RTC (Presiding Judge Soriano-Villadolid) found the Deed of Assignment forged, voided M.Y. Intercontinental’s copyright registrations, held petitioners liable for copyright infringement for importing, marketing and selling St. Mary’s books without consent, and awarded injunctive relief and damages (actual damages equal to 20% of gross sales; moral, exemplary damages; attorney’s fees and costs).

The Court of Appeals affirmed the RTC in toto on April 11, 2019. Petitioners filed a Petition for Review on ...(Pro-only)

Issues:

  • Is the Deed of Assignment genuine and valid so as to transfer copyright ownership to petitioners?
  • Is the declaratory relief ruling of the RTC of Mandaluyong binding and dispositive in the infringement case?
  • Did petitioners commit copyright infringement by importing, marketing, and selling the subject textbooks?
  • Were the damages (actual/proximate, moral, exemplary, attorney's fees) awarded by the trial court proper?
  • Should petitioners’ counterclaims for unpaid loan and purchase order obligations have been resolved in ...(Pro-only)

Ruling:

  • (Pro-only)

Ratio:

  • (Pro-only)

Doctrine:

  • (Pro-only)

Philippine legal research, made clearer
AI-generated research aids. Verify with Full Text.