Case Digest (G.R. No. L-33157)
Facts:
On June 2, 1959, Benito H. Lopez obtained a P20,000 loan from Prudential Bank and Trust Company, executed a promissory note, a Surety Bond No. 14164 with Philippine American General Insurance Co., Inc. (Philamgen) as surety, an Indemnity Agreement, and a written instrument titled "Stock Assignment Separate from Certificate" transferring 4,000 shares of Baguio Military Institute, Inc. to Philamgen, with the certificate endorsed and delivered. When Lopez defaulted, Philamgen paid Prudential Bank in 1963 and sued Lopez for reimbursement; the trial court dismissed the complaint but the Court of Appeals held the stock assignment was a pledge, awarded Philamgen reimbursement, and Lopez petitioned for certiorari.Issues:
- Was the transaction evidenced by the "Stock Assignment Separate from Certificate" a dation in payment or a pledge?
- Did the agreement or subsequent promises that third persons would buy the shares constitute a novation by substitution of debtor releasing Lopez?
Ru
Case Digest (G.R. No. L-33157)
Facts:
- Loan transaction and securities executed on June 2, 1959
- Benito H. Lopez obtained a loan of P20,000.00 from Prudential Bank and Trust Company and executed a promissory note due one year from June 2, 1959 with interest at ten percent per annum.
- Lopez executed Surety Bond No. 14164 with Philippine American General Insurance Co., Inc. (PHILAMGEN) as surety, whereby Lopez as principal and PHILAMGEN bound themselves jointly and severally to Prudential Bank for P20,000.00.
- Lopez executed an indemnity agreement in favor of PHILAMGEN obligating himself to indemnify PHILAMGEN against any damages, losses, costs, stamps, taxes, penalties, charges and expenses incurred by PHILAMGEN as surety.
- Stock assignment document and delivery contemporaneous with loan
- Lopez executed a document titled "Stock Assignment Separate from Certificate" by which he purported to "sell, assign, and transfer" four thousand shares of Baguio Military Institute, Inc. (Certificate No. 44) to PHILAMGEN "for and in consideration of the obligations undertaken" by PHILAMGEN under Surety Bond No. 14164 and "for value received," and appointed PHILAMGEN attorney to transfer the stock.
- Lopez endorsed the stock certificate in blank and delivered the certificate to PHILAMGEN.
- An understanding existed among Lopez, Emilio Abello (PHILAMGEN officer), and Prudential Bank representatives that if Lopez did not pay, Abello and Pio Pedrosa would buy the shares and use proceeds to pay the bank.
- Default, demands, and transfer of certificate in corporate books
- Lopez failed to pay when the obligation matured on June 2, 1960; Prudential Bank demanded payment from Lopez and PHILAMGEN; PHILAMGEN sent written demands to Lopez.
- Prudential Bank filed suit in August 1961 to enforce the note. After receipt of complaint, PHILAMGEN officers arranged to have the shares transferred to PHILAMGEN and Abello and Pedrosa promised to buy the shares from PHILAMGEN so proceeds could be paid to the bank.
- At PHILAMGEN's request, Baguio Military Institute cancelled Certificate No. 44 and issued Certificate No. 171 in the name of PHILAMGEN on November 17, 1961; the earlier complaint was dismissed.
- Subsequent suit, payment, and subrogation
- Prudential Bank filed another complaint on November 8, 1963 after no payment by Lopez or PHILAMGEN.
- Lopez wrote PHILAMGEN on November 18, 1963 inquiring about his shares "which were pledged to your goodselves to secure said obligation."
- PHILAMGEN paid Prudential Bank P27,785.89 on December 9, 1963 and obtained a subrogation receipt.
- Civil action by PHILAMGEN and trial court dismissal
- PHILAMGEN sued Lopez for reimbursement: Civil Case No. 60272, Court of First Instance of Manila.
- The trial court dismissed PHILAMGEN's complaint, finding the stock transfer was absolute and that PHILAMGEN had become owner, making recovery from Lopez unfair and amounting to double payment. The court held PHILAMGEN's appropriation of shares deprived it of the right to recover from Lopez.
- Appeal to Court of Appeals and its ruling
- PHILAMGEN appealed alleging the stock transfer was a pledge, not an absol...(Subscriber-Only)
Issues:
- Characterization of the stock transfer
- Whether the "sell, assign and transfer" document and the delivery of endorsed shares to PHILAMGEN, followed by entry of the certificate in PHILAMGEN's name after Lopez's default, constituted a dation in payment (dacion en pago) extinguishing the monetary obligation or instead constituted a pledge securing the obligation.
- Effect of third-party agreement on debtor's liability
- Whether the private agreement or understanding that Messrs. Abe...(Subscriber-Only)
Ruling:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Ratio:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Doctrine:
- (Subscriber-Only)