Fudot vs. Cattleya Land, Inc.

G.R. No. 171008
Cattleya Land, Inc. purchased property from Tecsons, but registration was delayed due to a notice of attachment. Carmelita Fudot claimed ownership via a 1986 deed, later found forged. Courts ruled in favor of Cattleya, affirming its good faith registration and invalidating Fudot’s claim. No double sale occurred.

Case Digest (G.R. No. 171008)

Facts:

Carmelita Fudot v. Cattleya Land, Inc., G.R. No. 171008, September 13, 2007, Supreme Court Second Division, Tinga, J., writing for the Court. Petitioner Carmelita Fudot seeks to nullify the Court of Appeals Decision dated 28 April 2005 and Resolution dated 11 January 2006 in C.A. G.R. CV No. 73025, which declared respondent Cattleya Land, Inc. as having the better right over a parcel of land in Doljo, Panglao, Bohol.

Sometime in July 1992 respondent instructed a third party to check the titles to nine lots (including the subject lot) owned by spouses Troadio and Asuncion Tecson; finding no defects, respondent executed a Deed of Conditional Sale on 6 November 1992 and a Deed of Absolute Sale on 30 August 1993, both later recorded with the Register of Deeds (entries dated 6 Nov 1992 and 4 Oct 1993). The Register of Deeds initially refused to annotate the sale because of a notice of attachment (Tantrade Corporation v. Troadio Tecson) which was later cancelled after respondent aided in a compromise; titles to six lots were issued but three remained unaccounted for.

On 23 January 1995 petitioner presented an owner’s copy of the title and a deed of sale dated 19 December 1986, and the Register of Deeds registered that deed and issued a new title in her name; respondent promptly filed a letter of protest. On 5 May 1995 respondent filed before the Regional Trial Court (Branch 4, Tagbilaran City; docketed Civil Case No. 5781) a Complaint for Quieting of Title and/or Recovery of Ownership and Cancellation of Title with Damages. On 26 June 1995 Asuncion Tecson filed a Complaint-in-Intervention alleging her signature on petitioner’s deed was forged and that she never consented to any sale of conjugal property.

On 31 October 2001 the trial court ruled: (i) quieting title in favor of respondent; (ii) declaring petitioner’s deed of sale invalid; (iii) ordering registration in favor of respondent; (iv) dismissing respondent’s damages claim against the Register of Deeds for insufficiency of evidence; (v) dismissing Asuncion’s damages claim against petitioner; and (vi) dismissing petitioner’s counterclaim. The trial court relied on its finding that Asuncion’s testimony that her signature was forged was convincing and unrebutted.

Petitioner appealed to the Court of Appeals, arguing primarily a double-sale rule in her favor. The Court of Appeals, in its 28 April 2005 Decision, affirmed the trial court: it found no double sale because petitioner’s deed was void for forgery and lack of marital consent, and it alternatively held resp...(Pro-only)

Issues:

  • Between two buyers of registered land, who has the better right — the first buyer who was given the owner’s duplicate TCT together with a deed of sale in 1986, or the second buyer in 1992 with only a deed of sale?
  • Is a buyer of registered land who did not demand or require delivery of the owner’s duplicate TCT nevertheless a buyer in good faith?
  • In subsequent registration of registered lands (as by sale), which law governs — Article 1544 of the Civil Code or ...(Pro-only)

Ruling:

  • (Pro-only)

Ratio:

  • (Pro-only)

Doctrine:

  • (Pro-only)

Philippine legal research, made clearer
AI-generated research aids. Verify with Full Text.