Case Digest (G.R. No. 247985)
Facts:
Raphy Valdez De Silva, G.R. No. 247985, October 13, 2021, the Supreme Court First Division, Lopez, J., writing for the Court.Petitioner Raphy Valdez De Silva filed a petition under Article 36 of the Family Code for declaration of nullity of her 25 June 2005 marriage to respondent Donald De Silva; the Republic of the Philippines was impleaded pursuant to the rules. Petitioner alleged that respondent was psychologically incapacitated to comply with the essential marital obligations due to long‑standing personality traits that manifested in gambling, drinking, infidelity, threats, physical and verbal abuse, misappropriation of conjugal funds, loans incurred without her knowledge, and repeated incidents that culminated in petitioner’s hospitalization for trauma in 2011 and her leaving the conjugal home in April 2012.
Before the Regional Trial Court (RTC), petitioner presented documentary evidence (medical receipts, a Barangay Protection Order, a police certification), the judicial affidavit of her mother Rosalina Valdez y Calugay, and a Psychological Assessment Report by clinical psychologist Dr. Nedy L. Tayag, which diagnosed respondent with Anti‑Social Personality Disorder and traced its roots to his upbringing prior to the marriage. Respondent answered denying the alleged incapacity, denying sustained gambling, drunkenness, infidelity and physical abuse, and claiming efforts at reconciliation and family support.
On 11 November 2015 the RTC, Branch 73, Antipolo City, rendered judgment declaring the marriage void ab initio under Article 36, crediting petitioner’s witnesses and Dr. Tayag’s report and finding reconciliation improbable due to the parties’ de facto separation since 2012. Respondent appealed to the Court of Appeals (CA). On 26 February 2019 the CA in CA‑G.R. CV No. 108537 reversed and set aside the RTC, dismissing the petition on the ground that the totality of evidence did not prove a psychological condition so severe as to render respondent incapable of marital obligations; the CA found Dr. Tayag’s report suspect and overly reliant on information from petitioner and her mother and noted that respondent’s phone interview with the psychologist was too brief. The CA denied petitioner’s motion for reconsideration on 14 June 2019.
Petitioner elevated ...(Pro-only)
Issues:
- Did the Court of Appeals err in holding that petitioner failed to establish that respondent was suffering from a severe psychological condition rendering him incapable of complying with essential marital obligations?
- Did the Court of Appeals err in holding that petitioner failed to establish the medical or clinical root cause (and its juridical antecedence and incurability) of respondent’s ...(Pro-only)
Ruling:
- (Pro-only)
Ratio:
- (Pro-only)
Doctrine:
- (Pro-only)