Case Digest (G.R. No. 78997)
Facts:
- Veronica B. Reyes was employed as a teacher at Kong Hua School starting August 1972.
- She went on maternity leave on August 26, 1982, which lasted until October 10, 1982.
- Due to complications from childbirth, Reyes requested an extension of her leave and later applied for an indefinite leave of absence.
- On December 21, 1982, she attempted to return to work but suffered a nervous breakdown after one day.
- Following the Christmas break, her request for another indefinite leave was denied by the school.
- On September 13, 1983, Reyes expressed her intention to resign, requesting two months' vacation pay and hoping for re-employment later.
- Her husband submitted another resignation letter on her behalf, citing her physical incapacity.
- The school paid her the requested vacation pay.
- In June 1985, after recovering, Reyes applied for reinstatement, but Kong Hua School refused.
- Reyes filed a complaint with the NLRC for reinstatement, back wages, and benefits.
- The labor arbiter dismissed her complaint, interpreting it as a claim for separation pay, which was also dismissed.
- Reyes appealed to the NLRC, which upheld the labor arbiter's decision, stating her resignation was voluntary.
- This led Reyes to seek relief from the Supreme Court.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court ruled that Reyes' resignation was involuntary.
- Reyes is entitled to separation pay due to the circumstances surrounding her resignation. ...(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The Supreme Court determined that the circumstances of Reyes' resignation indicated it was not voluntary.
- Reyes was under duress, as her resignation was influenced by the school administration's promise of priority for re-employment and the urgent need for her vacation pay.
- The Court emphasized that the school had no right to deny her indefinite leave due to her health issues stemming from childbirth complications.
- Under Article 133(b) of the Labor Code, maternity leave should be extended for illnesses related to pregn...continue reading
Case Digest (G.R. No. 78997)
Facts:
The case involves Veronica B. Reyes as the petitioner and the National Labor Relations Commission (NLRC) and Kong Hua School as the respondents. The events leading to the case began in August 1972 when Reyes commenced her employment as a school teacher at Kong Hua School. On August 26, 1982, she went on maternity leave, which lasted until October 10, 1982. Due to complications from childbirth, Reyes requested an extension of her leave and subsequently applied for an indefinite leave of absence until she was fit to return to work. On December 21, 1982, she attempted to resume her duties but was only able to teach for one day before suffering a nervous breakdown. Following the Christmas break, she again sought an indefinite leave of absence due to her health issues, but this request was denied by the school administration.
On September 13, 1983, upon the advice of the school principal, Reyes submitted a letter expressing her intention to resign while also requesting her two months' vacation pay from April-May 1982. She stated her hope that she would be given priority for re-employment when she was ready to return. Two weeks later, her husband submitted another resignation letter on her behalf, citing her physical incapacity to teach. The school subsequently paid her the vacation pay she requested. In June 1985, after recovering her health, Reyes applied for reinstatement, but Kong Hua School refused to rehire her. Consequently, she filed a complaint with the...