Case Digest (G.R. No. L-21902)
Facts:
- The case involves the Manila Railroad Company (petitioner) and the Workmen's Compensation Commission along with Ricardo Balmeo (respondents).
- Ricardo Balmeo began working as a temporary trackman on July 1, 1958, after passing a pre-employment physical examination.
- He was appointed as a permanent trackman on August 16, 1960, with an annual salary of P1,500.
- His job involved physically demanding tasks, including lifting iron rails and working in harsh weather conditions.
- On January 11, 1961, Balmeo was diagnosed with pulmonary tuberculosis after an X-ray examination.
- Despite his illness, he continued working until his dismissal on June 16, 1961.
- Balmeo filed a claim for disability compensation on October 10, 1961, after being dismissed.
- The Manila Railroad Company contested the claim, submitting an employer's report on November 10, 1961.
- A hearing officer ruled in favor of Balmeo, awarding him compensation benefits.
- The Manila Railroad Company appealed to the Workmen's Compensation Commission, which affirmed the hearing officer's decision on July 15, 1963.
- The company's motion for reconsideration was denied on August 23, 1963.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court dismissed the Manila Railroad Company's petition for review.
- The Court affirmed the decision of the Workmen's Compensation Commission, confirming its jurisdiction over Balmeo's claim. ...(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The Court emphasized that failure to comply with notice and filing requirements under Section 24 of Act 3428 does not create a jurisdictional defect.
- If the employer is aware of the employee's illness or injury, the lack of timely notice does not prevent the claim for compensation....continue reading
Case Digest (G.R. No. L-21902)
Facts:
The case involves the Manila Railroad Company as the petitioner and the Workmen's Compensation Commission along with Ricardo Balmeo as the respondents. The events leading to this case began when Ricardo Balmeo commenced his employment with the Manila Railroad Company as a temporary trackman on July 1, 1958, after passing a pre-employment physical examination. He was later appointed as a permanent trackman on August 16, 1960, with an annual salary of P1,500. His duties included physically demanding tasks such as lifting iron rails, loading and unloading materials, and making repairs on railways, exposing him to harsh weather conditions.
On January 11, 1961, after approximately two years of service, Balmeo underwent an X-ray examination that revealed he was suffering from pulmonary tuberculosis. Despite this diagnosis, he continued to perform his duties until he was dismissed on June 16, 1961, due to his illness. Almost four months later, on October 10, 1961, Balmeo filed a claim for disability compensation with the Department of Labor's Regional Office No. 4. The Manila Railroad Company submitted its employer's report of accident or sickness on November 10, 1961, indicating its intention to contest Balmeo's claim.
After a trial, the hearing officer ruled in favor of Balmeo, declaring his claim meritorious and awarding him compensation benefits. The Manila Railroad Company subsequently appealed this decision to the Workmen's Compensation Commission, arguing that the decision was contrary to law and that there was no aggravation...