Case Digest (G.R. No. 84847)
Facts:
- Petitioners: Henry L. Koa and Virginia Koa.
- Respondents: Honorable Court of Appeals and BA Finance Corporation.
- On April 20, 1977, the Koa spouses secured a credit of P26,422.20 from People’s Car, Inc. for a Volkswagen Trakbayan de Luxe.
- The credit was backed by a promissory note with a 14% interest on unpaid installments, payable in monthly installments of P733.95 for 36 months, starting July 1, 1977.
- A penalty of P10.00 was imposed for each month of unpaid installments.
- The Koa spouses executed a chattel mortgage on the vehicle for compliance.
- On May 27, 1977, People’s Car, Inc. assigned the promissory note and chattel mortgage to BA Finance Corporation.
- The Koa spouses paid P14,679.00, leaving an unpaid balance of P12,236.98, plus interest and penalties.
- BA Finance Corporation filed a complaint for "Replevin with Damages" due to over six months of non-payment.
- The Koa spouses filed an Answer and a Third-Party Complaint against People’s Car, Inc.
- The Regional Trial Court ruled in favor of BA Finance Corporation, ordering payment of the unpaid balance and dismissing the third-party complaint.
- The Koa spouses appealed to the Court of Appeals, which affirmed the trial court's decision.
- Their motion for reconsideration was denied, leading to a petition for review on certiorari.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court found merit in the Koa spouses' argument that BA Finance Corporation was bound by the warranty obligations of People’s Car, Inc.
- The Court ruled that the Koa spouses should be exonerated from paying the balance due to the principle against unjust enrichment....(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The Supreme Court emphasized that when a seller assigns a credit to another party, the assignee inherits both the rights and obligations of the seller.
- BA Finance Corporation, as the assignee, was bound by the same terms as the original agreement with People’s Car, Inc.
- The Court cited...continue reading
Case Digest (G.R. No. 84847)
Facts:
The case involves petitioners Henry L. Koa and Virginia Koa against the respondents, the Honorable Court of Appeals and BA Finance Corporation. The events leading to the case began on April 20, 1977, when the Koa spouses obtained a credit of P26,422.20 from People’s Car, Inc. for a Volkswagen Trakbayan de Luxe. This credit was secured by a promissory note executed by the spouses, obligating them to pay the amount with a 14% interest on unpaid installments, payable in monthly installments of P733.95 starting July 1, 1977, for 36 months. The agreement included a penalty charge of P10.00 for each month or fraction thereof for any unpaid installment. To ensure compliance, the Koa spouses constituted a chattel mortgage on the vehicle.
On May 27, 1977, People’s Car, Inc. assigned the promissory note and chattel mortgage to BA Finance Corporation. The Koa spouses made payments totaling P14,679.00, leaving an unpaid balance of P12,236.98, plus interest and penalties. Due to the Koa spouses' failure to comply with the payment terms for over six months, BA Finance Corporation filed a complaint for "Replevin with Damages" against them. The Koa spouses responded with an Answer and a Third-Party Complaint against People’s Car, Inc.
The Regional Trial Court ruled in favor of BA Finance Corporation, ordering the Koa spouses to pay the unpaid balance, interest, and attorney's fees, while dismissing the third-party complaint. The Koa spouses appealed to the Court of Appeals, ...