Case Digest (G.R. No. L-41423)
Facts:
- Luis Joseph is the petitioner; respondents include Hon. Crispin V. Bautista, Patrocinio Perez, Antonio Sioson, Jacinto Pagarigan, Alberto Cardeno, and Lazaro Villanueva.
- On January 12, 1973, Luis Joseph took a cargo truck owned by Patrocinio Perez, driven by Domingo Villa, from Dagupan City to Valenzuela, Bulacan for a fare of P9.00.
- The cargo truck attempted to overtake a tricycle, while a pick-up truck, allegedly owned by Antonio Sioson and Jacinto Pagarigan and driven by Lazaro Villanueva, also attempted to overtake the cargo truck.
- This maneuver caused the cargo truck to veer off the road and crash into a mango tree, resulting in Luis Joseph sustaining a leg fracture.
- Luis Joseph filed a complaint for damages against Patrocinio Perez for breach of contract of carriage and against Antonio Sioson and Lazaro Villanueva for quasi-delict.
- The case was presided over by Judge Crispin V. Bautista in the Court of First Instance of Bulacan, Branch II.
- Defendants included Domingo Villa, who did not respond, and Rosario Vargas, who could not be served with summons.
- Various motions and claims were filed, including a cross-claim by Perez against her co-defendants for indemnity.
- On September 27, 1974, the respondents paid Luis Joseph P1,300.00 for his injuries, leading him to execute a release of claim against them.
- Perez later received P7,420.61 for damages to her truck from the same respondents.
- On July 8, 1975, Judge Bautista dismissed the case, ruling that the release of claim benefited Perez, prompting Luis Joseph to file a motion for reconsideration, which was denied.
Issue:
- (Unlock)
Ruling:
- The Supreme Court affirmed the trial court's orders, upholding the dismissal of the case against Patrocinio Perez.
- The Court ruled that the release of claim executed by L...(Unlock)
Ratio:
- The Court's decision was based on the principle of solidary liability among the respondents.
- It established that when one solidary debtor pays the entire obligation, the other solidary debtors are released from liability.
- The Court clarified that there was only one cause of action arising from a single injury sustained by Luis Joseph, despite mult...continue reading
Case Digest (G.R. No. L-41423)
Facts:
The case involves Luis Joseph as the petitioner and Hon. Crispin V. Bautista, Patrocinio Perez, Antonio Sioson, Jacinto Pagarigan, Alberto Cardeno, and Lazaro Villanueva as respondents. The events leading to this case began on January 12, 1973, when Luis Joseph boarded a cargo truck owned by Patrocinio Perez, driven by Domingo Villa, for a fare of P9.00 from Dagupan City to Valenzuela, Bulacan. While traveling, the cargo truck attempted to overtake a tricycle, during which a pick-up truck, allegedly owned by Antonio Sioson and Jacinto Pagarigan and driven by Lazaro Villanueva, also attempted to overtake the cargo truck. This maneuver forced the cargo truck to veer off the road and crash into a mango tree, resulting in Luis Joseph sustaining a leg fracture.
Subsequently, Luis Joseph filed a complaint for damages against Patrocinio Perez for breach of contract of carriage and against Antonio Sioson and Lazaro Villanueva for quasi-delict. The case was presided over by Judge Crispin V. Bautista in the Court of First Instance of Bulacan, Branch II. The defendants included Domingo Villa, who did not respond to the complaint, and Rosario Vargas, who could not be served with summons. The proceedings saw various motions and claims, including a cross-claim by Perez against her co-defendants for indemnity. On September 27, 1974, the respondents paid Luis Joseph...