Case Digest (G.R. No. L-26316)
Facts:
The case involves Antero Canonigo, Francisco Artajo, and Beata Morilao as petitioners-appellees against Hilarion Ramiro, the immediate past City Mayor of Ozamiz City, and other city officials as respondents-appellants. The events leading to the case began on August 10, 1960, when the petitioners filed a petition for mandamus with a preliminary injunction against the city officials, seeking reinstatement to their positions as field clerks and market inspector in the office of the City Treasurer. The petition was amended on January 18, 1961, to include claims for moral and exemplary damages, and again on September 11, 1965, to include the current city officials due to the elections held in 1963.
The petitioners were appointed to their respective positions by then-City Mayor Angel Medina, with Canonigo appointed on July 1, 1959, Morilao on August 17, 1959, and Artajo on September 1, 1959. All appointments were approved by the Commissioner of Civil Service and were considered p...
Case Digest (G.R. No. L-26316)
Facts:
Appointments and Positions:
- Antero Canonigo was appointed as a field clerk in the office of the City Treasurer of Ozamiz City on July 1, 1959, with a salary of P1,440.00 per annum. His appointment was later made permanent and approved by the Commissioner of Civil Service.
- Beata Morilao was appointed as a regular field clerk on August 17, 1959, with a salary of P1,440.00 per annum. Her appointment was also approved by the Commissioner of Civil Service.
- Francisco Artajo was appointed as a market inspector on September 1, 1959, with a salary of P1,800.00 per annum. His appointment was approved despite his eligibility being that of a patrolman.
Change in Administration:
- In the 1959 elections, Mayor Angel Medina was defeated by Mayor Hilarion Ramiro. Upon assuming office, Mayor Ramiro requested the petitioners to tender their "courtesy resignations" to give the new administration a "free hand." The petitioners refused to resign.
Abolition of Positions:
- On May 3, 1960, the Municipal Board of Ozamiz City passed Resolution No. 282, abolishing the positions of field clerks and market inspectors. The petitioners were informed of the termination of their services on May 5, 1960.
Subsequent Employment:
- Antero Canonigo secured employment as a public school teacher starting August 1, 1963.
- Beata Morilao was employed in the City Auditor's Office starting January 9, 1961.
- Francisco Artajo remained unemployed after his termination.
Creation of New Positions:
- After the abolition of the petitioners' positions, the Municipal Board created various new positions and appropriated funds for salaries and improvements.
Issue:
- Whether the City of Ozamiz can be compelled by mandamus to recreate positions it had abolished.
- Whether the appointments of the petitioners were permanent or conditional.
- Whether the abolition of the petitioners' positions constituted removal or dismissal.
- Whether the abolition of the positions was done in bad faith.
- Whether the decision of the lower court is supported by law.
Ruling:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Ratio:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Conclusion:
The Supreme Court upheld the lower court's decision, ruling that the abolition of the petitioners' positions was illegal and done in bad faith. The petitioners were entitled to reinstatement and back salaries, and the City of Ozamiz was liable for the payment of these salaries. The writ of mandamus was granted to enforce these rights.