Case Digest (G.R. No. L-11750)
Facts:
The case of Anunciacion Bobiles vs. Leander Almine, et al. (G.R. No. L-11750) was decided on May 28, 1958. The plaintiff-appellant, Anunciacion Bobiles, filed a suit against the defendant-appellees, Leander Almine and his parents, in the Court of First Instance of Masbate. Bobiles sought to recover damages for the alleged breach of promise of marriage by Leander Almine. She claimed that she relied on Almine's pledges of sincere love and commitment to marry her, which led her to grant him the privileges typically associated with a marital relationship. As a result of this relationship, she gave birth to a baby boy. However, Almine later refused to fulfill his promise of marriage without any justification. Bobiles also alleged that Almine's parents assisted him in his deceitful actions and should be held accountable for their son's behavior. In her complaint, she specified the damages she sought and requested other forms of relief. During the trial, witnesses testif...
Case Digest (G.R. No. L-11750)
Facts:
Background of the Case:
Anunciacion Bobiles filed a lawsuit against Leander Almine and his parents, seeking damages for breach of promise of marriage. She alleged that Leander had promised to marry her, and based on his assurances of love and matrimony, she allowed him the privileges of a husband, which resulted in her giving birth to a child. However, Leander later refused to fulfill his promise, and his parents allegedly aided him in his deceitful actions. Bobiles sought compensation for the damages she suffered due to this breach of promise.
Evidence Presented:
- Testimonial Evidence: Witnesses testified in support of Bobiles' claims.
- Documentary Evidence: Letters written by Leander Almine were introduced as evidence. One such letter (Exhibit A) contained the following statement:
"In my vision I hold you and me kneeling and praying before a priest in front of the altar swearing to be true to each other until death separates us."
Trial Court Decision:
The trial court found that while carnal relations between Bobiles and Leander had been proven, there was insufficient evidence to establish a promise of marriage. Consequently, the court dismissed the case. Bobiles appealed, asserting that the evidence sufficiently proved the existence of a promise of marriage.
Issue:
- Whether the evidence presented by Bobiles sufficiently established a promise of marriage by Leander Almine.
- Whether the appeal should be decided by the Supreme Court or the Court of Appeals, given the nature of the questions raised (questions of law vs. questions of fact).
Ruling:
- (Subscriber-Only)
Ratio:
- (Subscriber-Only)